The comparison between Marine Plywood (IS 710 grade) and Multiwood depends on the application. Here's a detailed comparison across key parameters:
1. Composition
Marine Plywood (IS 710 Grade):
Made from high-quality hardwood veneers bonded with BWP (Boiling Water Proof) phenol-formaldehyde resin.
Has layers (plies) of wood pressed together in cross-grain structure.
Multiwood:
Not wood-based. It is a uPVC (unplasticized polyvinyl chloride) or polymer-based sheet.
Manufactured using plastic composites and calcium carbonate; doesn’t have any natural wood layers.
🔹 2. Water Resistance
Marine Plywood:
Extremely water-resistant, suitable for high-humidity or coastal environments.
Still, can absorb water over time and needs sealing at edges.
Multiwood:
100% waterproof, termite-proof, and does not absorb moisture.
Preferred in bathrooms, modular kitchens, or damp areas.
Winner: Multiwood (for moisture-heavy environments)
3. Strength and Load-Bearing Capacity
Marine Plywood:
Stronger structurally; better load-bearing capacity.
Holds screws and nails better.
Multiwood:
Not as structurally strong.
Can warp under heavy load or over long spans.
Winner: Marine Plywood (for structural or load-bearing use)
4. Workability
Marine Plywood:
Works like natural wood. Easy to saw, screw, paint, or veneer.
Multiwood:
Can be cut and screwed, but tends to chip or crack if not handled carefully.
Needs special fasteners in some cases.
Winner: Marine Plywood (for carpentry or detailed finishes)
5. Durability & Lifespan
Marine Plywood:
Can last 15–25 years with proper sealing and care.
Vulnerable to termites if untreated.
Multiwood:
Inert to termites, rust, or rot.
Durable in damp areas but can turn brittle over time if exposed to harsh sunlight.
Tie: Depends on exposure — Marine ply (for strength & finish), Multiwood (for moisture & termite resistance)
6. Cost
Marine Plywood:
Generally cheaper than Multiwood for the same thickness.
Multiwood:
More expensive, especially for thicker boards.
Winner: Marine Plywood (budget-friendly)
7. Eco-Friendliness
Marine Plywood:
Uses natural wood, but involves tree felling.
Formaldehyde content can be a concern in cheaper brands.
Multiwood:
Synthetic and non-biodegradable; not eco-friendly.
Winner: Marine Plywood (relatively better for sustainability)
When to Choose What
Use Case Recommended Material
Modular kitchen in dry zones Marine Plywood (IS 710)
Bathroom cabinets Multiwood
Wall panels/furniture near water sources Multiwood
Beds, tables, wardrobes Marine Plywood
Long-term heavy-duty furniture Marine Plywood
Zero-maintenance outdoor cabinets (shade only) Multiwood
Verdict
Marine Plywood is better for structural strength, finish, long-term use, and custom woodwork.
Multiwood is better for wet areas, low-maintenance needs, and termite-proofing.
No comments:
Post a Comment