Thursday, November 19, 2026

Gujarat Calling ~ Bhale Padharya

 

ભલે પધાર્યા” ~ Bhale Padharya

Come. You are welcome.

There are journeys that take us from one destination to another, and then there are journeys that slowly reveal a land.

Gujarat was one such journey for me.

I arrived in Ahmedabad with a map in my mind and a curiosity that was much larger than the map. What I did not know then was that Gujarat would keep changing its character as we travelled through it. From the bustling lanes of Ahmedabad to the grandeur of Vadodara, from the towering Statue of Unity to the ancient shores of Somnath, from the silent forests of Gir to the sacred city of Dwarka, and finally to the vast white emptiness of Kutch—the journey seemed less like travelling across one state and more like travelling through several different worlds.

Gujarat was calling. And we answered.

 


Looking back, what stays with me is not one monument or one temple.

It is the extraordinary variety.

Ahmedabad gave us history and Gandhi.

Vadodara gave us royalty and culture.

The Statue of Unity gave us scale and the Narmada.

Somnath gave us faith beside the sea.

Gir gave us the wild.

Dwarka gave us Krishna and mythology.

Kutch gave us silence, salt, colour and infinity.

And perhaps that is the real beauty of Gujarat.

It refuses to be one thing.

It can be ancient and modern.

Spiritual and entrepreneurial.

Wild and deeply cultivated.

Colourful and stark.

Crowded and profoundly silent.

It carries temples and mosques, palaces and stepwells, forests and deserts, bustling cities and lonely horizons.

And everywhere, there is that characteristic Gujarati warmth—the simple invitation:

 

Gujarat — A journey of many worlds




Ahmedabad — Where the old and the new live together

Our journey began in Ahmedabad, a city that seems to have mastered the art of living with its past without becoming imprisoned by it.

Ahmedabad is India's first UNESCO World Heritage City, and its history is visible not only in monuments but in the very rhythm of its old neighbourhoods. The Walled City, with its pols, intricately carved houses, old gates and narrow lanes, carries memories of another era. Yet just across the Sabarmati lies a very different Ahmedabad—modern, ambitious and constantly moving forward.

The Sabarmati Ashram.



We kept it for the last.

There was something deeply moving about standing in a place where simplicity once became a form of strength. The Sabarmati flowed quietly nearby, while the ashram seemed almost deliberately modest. It was difficult not to think of Gandhi walking through these very surroundings, carrying an idea that would eventually travel far beyond Gujarat.

Ahmedabad offered other stories too—the exquisite jaalis of the Sidi Saiyyed Mosque, the quiet elegance of Jain temples, the old pols, bustling markets and the flavours of Gujarati food.

The city seemed to whisper rather than announce itself.

Perhaps that is what made it memorable.

Ahmedabad was not merely the beginning of our journey. It was our first lesson: heritage does not have to stand still.





Rani ki Vav at Patan, that extraordinary stepwell where architecture descends into the earth; the Sun Temple at Modhera, where stone and sunlight meet were mesmerizing 






Vadodara — A city of palaces and culture

From Ahmedabad, we travelled towards Vadodara.

If Ahmedabad felt like a conversation between history and modernity, Vadodara felt more regal.

The city has long been associated with the Gaekwad dynasty, and nowhere is that legacy more visible than at the magnificent Laxmi Vilas Palace. The scale of the palace, its architecture and its sprawling grounds make it easy to imagine the grandeur of the princely era. Vadodara is often described as the cultural capital of Gujarat, and its palaces, museums and artistic traditions give the description substance.

But Vadodara was only a pause before something much larger awaited us.

The Statue of Unity.

The Statue of Unity — When a monument becomes a landscape

As we approached Kevadia, the landscape began to change.

And then, almost suddenly, the Statue of Unity appeared.

At 182 metres, it is an astonishing sight—not merely because of its height, but because of the way it rises against the hills and the Narmada landscape. The statue commemorates Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel and stands beside the Sardar Sarovar project, surrounded by the Satpura and Vindhya ranges.

Standing below it, one feels very small.

Yet the most memorable part was not simply the statue itself.

It was the landscape around it.

The Narmada moved through the valley. The hills stood quietly in the distance. The vastness of the surroundings seemed to give meaning to the monument.

Here, human engineering and nature seemed to share the same stage.

We had come to see a statue.

We left having experienced a landscape.


The night light show was amazing.

Gir — Into the kingdom of the Asiatic lion

Our journey took us into the wild.

Gir is not merely another wildlife destination. It is special because it is the last remaining natural home of the Asiatic lion.






The landscape here is very different from the image of an African safari that many of us carry in our imagination.

The forest is dry, rugged and beautiful in its own way.

We travelled through the forest with our eyes constantly searching.

A movement in the bushes.

A sudden silence.

A distant call.

Every turn seemed to hold a possibility.

And then came the thought that perhaps wildlife travel is not really about seeing an animal.

It is about learning to wait.

Nature does not perform on demand.

It reveals itself when it chooses.

Gir taught us that.

Somnath — Where the sea meets eternity

From the world of monuments, we travelled towards the Arabian Sea.

Somnath has a different kind of grandeur.

Here, the first impression is not of height or scale, but of permanence.

The Somnath temple stands beside the sea, and the sound of waves seems to accompany the prayers. The temple is revered as one of the twelve Jyotirlingas, and its location by the ocean creates an atmosphere unlike any other temple I had experienced. Gujarat Tourism itself describes Somnath as one of the state's foremost pilgrimage destinations.

I found myself drawn repeatedly towards the sea.

There was something beautiful about watching the waves arrive, break and retreat, only to return again.

Perhaps that is why places of pilgrimage often become more than places of worship.

They make us think about time.

About beginnings and endings.

About what disappears and what remains.

At Somnath, the temple stood firm while the sea continued its ancient rhythm beside it.

Dwarka — Following the footsteps of Krishna

From the forest, we moved towards the sea again, this time towards Dwarka.

The atmosphere changed almost immediately.

Dwarka is not simply a temple town. It is a city carrying the enormous weight of mythology.

The name itself evokes Krishna, the ancient city of Dwaraka and stories that have travelled across generations.

At the Dwarkadhish Temple, devotion fills the streets and the surrounding spaces. Gujarat Tourism describes Dwarka as one of the great Hindu pilgrimage centres and a Char Dham destination.

Here, mythology did not feel like something confined to a book.

It seemed to live in the chants, the flags, the pilgrims, the sea and the stories people carried with them.

There are places where history tells us what happened.

And there are places where faith tells us what might have happened.

Dwarka belongs to the second kind.











Kutch — Where the earth becomes sky

And then came Kutch.

Perhaps no other part of our journey prepared us for what we saw here.

The landscape became increasingly sparse.

The colours changed.

The horizon expanded.

And suddenly, the earth seemed to dissolve into an enormous white expanse.

The Great Rann of Kutch is difficult to describe because photographs can capture its appearance but not its feeling.

Standing there, one loses the usual reference points.

There are no crowded streets.

No buildings competing for attention.

No familiar landscape to hold on to.

Just white salt, sky and horizon.

And silence.

Kutch is not empty, though.

Its real richness lies in its people and their art.

The region is renowned for its textiles and embroidery, particularly the intricate mirror work for which Kutch is famous. Its villages carry traditions that have survived across generations.

The colours of the embroidery seemed almost to answer the starkness of the Rann.

Where nature had created a landscape of white, people had created a world of red, blue, yellow, green, mirrors and intricate patterns.

It was as though the people of Kutch had decided that if the landscape was going to be vast and austere, their art would be exuberant.











We walked along the road to heaven. We also admired Dholavira —walked through one of the remarkable archaeological landscapes of the Harappan civilisation.






And then there was the sunset

Somewhere in Kutch, as the sun began to descend, the white desert changed colour.

For a few moments, the landscape seemed almost unreal.

The salt reflected the evening light.

The sky turned softer.

The horizon stretched endlessly.

And I understood something about travel that photographs can never quite explain.

We travel to see places.

But sometimes, a place changes the way we see.

Kutch was one of those places.

The people.

And so Gujarat does what the best journeys always do.

It does not say goodbye.

It leaves a few doors open.

A few roads unexplored.

A few stories unfinished.

Places left for another journey

Every journey ends with a list of places that remain.

Gujarat, fortunately, leaves us with a rather long one.

We missed Champaner-Pavagadh, a UNESCO World Heritage landscape of temples, mosques and historic remains. These are among the places Gujarat Tourism itself highlights as important destinations.

Girnar remains unfinished business, its hills and temples waiting for a slower journey.

So does Palitana, one of Gujarat's great Jain pilgrimage centres.

There is Velavadar, with its blackbuck and grasslands; Little Rann of Kutch, with its distinctive wildlife and salt landscape; Polo Forest, where forest, history and ancient ruins meet; and Nalsarovar, where the landscape opens into a world of birds and wetlands.

And perhaps there should be another journey simply for the villages of Kutch—to sit with artisans, watch embroidery being created, listen to stories and understand the lives behind the colours.

Because perhaps that is what we missed most.

Not another monument.

Not another photograph.

And somewhere in the distance, the Rann is still glowing under the evening sky.

Gujarat is calling again.

Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Room


 Guess whose room could be like this?

Would you like your room to be like this?

Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Derivatives

 Derivatives are contracts whose value is linked to something else—a currency, share, commodity, interest rate, index, etc.

1. A company locking in the USD/INR exchange rate — Forward

Imagine an Indian company knows it must pay a US supplier $1 million after three months.

Today, USD/INR is ₹88. The company is worried that the dollar may become more expensive.

It enters into a forward contract with a bank:

“After three months, I will buy $1 million at ₹89 per dollar.”

Three months later:

  • If USD = ₹93 → the company benefits because it gets the dollars at ₹89.
  • If USD = ₹85 → the company would have been better off buying at the market rate, but it is still committed to ₹89.

The value of the forward contract therefore changes with the USD/INR exchange rate.

Real-life use: companies use currency forwards to hedge foreign-currency payments and receipts.


2. An airline protecting itself against rising fuel prices — Futures

An airline knows it will need a huge quantity of aviation fuel over the next six months.

It worries that oil prices may rise.

It enters into oil futures contracts.

If oil prices subsequently rise, the gain on the futures can offset some of the increased cost of fuel.

The airline isn't necessarily trying to make money from oil. It is trying to make its future fuel cost more predictable.

Underlying: oil price
Derivative: oil futures contract
Purpose: hedging


3. An investor buying the right to buy shares — Call option

Suppose Reliance shares are trading at ₹1,400.

You believe the price may rise, but you don't want to risk buying the shares outright.

You buy an option giving you the right, but not the obligation, to buy the shares at ₹1,450 within a specified period.

If the share price rises to ₹1,600, the option could become valuable.

If the share price remains below ₹1,450, you can simply allow the option to expire. Your loss is generally limited to the premium you paid for the option.

Underlying: Reliance share price
Derivative: call option


4. Protecting a share portfolio against a market crash — Put option

Imagine you own shares worth ₹50 lakh.

You are worried that the stock market may fall, but you don't want to sell your investments.

You buy put options.

If the market falls sharply, the put options can increase in value and partly offset your loss on the shares.

It is similar to buying protection against a fall in the market.

Underlying: share/index price
Derivative: put option
Purpose: hedging


5. A company exchanging fixed interest for floating interest — Interest-rate swap

Suppose a company has a ₹100 crore loan at a floating interest rate.

Management is worried that interest rates may rise.

The company enters into an interest-rate swap with a bank:

The company pays a fixed rate and receives a floating rate.

If market interest rates rise, the amount received under the swap can offset the higher interest cost on the underlying loan.

This is extremely common in corporate treasury.

Underlying: interest rate
Derivative: interest-rate swap


6. An Indian exporter protecting its dollar receipts — Forward

This is the reverse of the importer example.

Suppose an Indian IT company expects to receive $5 million in three months.

Today:

USD/INR = ₹88

The company worries that the dollar might fall to ₹83.

It enters into a forward contract to sell its dollars at ₹87.

If USD/INR subsequently falls to ₹83, the company has protected its rupee receipts.

Again, the derivative is not the dollars themselves. It is the contract whose value changes with the exchange rate.


7. A farmer locking in the price of wheat — Futures

Suppose a wheat farmer expects to harvest 10,000 tonnes in six months.

He worries that wheat prices may fall by harvest time.

He enters into wheat futures.

If wheat prices fall, the farmer may lose money on the physical wheat but gain on the futures contract.

If wheat prices rise, the reverse happens.

The farmer is using the derivative to reduce price uncertainty.

This is one of the oldest and most intuitive examples of derivatives.


The pattern behind all of them

You can think of it like this:

Something important to you → uncertainty about its future price → derivative contract → protection or exposure management

Real-life situationUnderlyingDerivative
Importer worried about dollar becoming expensiveUSD/INRForward
Exporter worried about dollar becoming cheaperUSD/INRForward
Airline worried about fuel pricesOilFutures
Farmer worried about wheat prices fallingWheatFutures
Investor expecting a share price to riseShare priceCall option
Investor protecting against a market fallShare/indexPut option
Company worried about rising loan ratesInterest rateInterest-rate swap


A derivative doesn't have to be used for speculation.

In fact, many derivatives in the real world are used by companies simply to manage risk.

An Indian company buying a USD forward isn't necessarily betting on the dollar. It may simply be saying:

“I know I have a dollar exposure. I don't want an exchange-rate surprise to disrupt my budget.”

That is why derivatives are so important in corporate finance—and why hedge accounting under IFRS 9 becomes relevant.

an insurance contract is not generally a derivative contract. The distinction is important, particularly under IFRS 9 and IFRS 17.

The simplest way to remember it

A derivative gets its value from an underlying variable and is settled based on changes in that variable.

Examples:

  • Forward contract → value depends on an exchange rate or price
  • Option → value depends on an underlying share, currency, commodity, etc.
  • Interest-rate swap → value depends on interest rates

An insurance contract, on the other hand, exists primarily to transfer significant insurance risk from the policyholder to the insurer.

For example:

You pay ₹20,000 for health insurance. If a covered medical event occurs, the insurer may have to pay ₹5 lakh.

The payment depends on the occurrence of an uncertain insured event, rather than simply on the movement of an underlying financial variable.

Why the confusion arises

There is an overlap in the mechanics.

Suppose a contract says:

“I will pay you ₹10 lakh if the temperature falls below 5°C.”

That could look like insurance. But if the contract does not involve significant insurance risk and instead its payout is based purely on an observable variable such as temperature, it may be treated as a derivative under IFRS 9.

So the key question is not simply:

“Does the contract pay when something uncertain happens?”

It is:

“Does the contract transfer significant insurance risk?”

A useful comparison

Insurance contractDerivative
Main purposeTransfer insurance riskGain/hedge exposure to an underlying
Key uncertaintyInsured eventMovement in underlying variable
ExampleLife/health/fire insuranceForward, option, swap
Main IFRSIFRS 17IFRS 9
Significant insurance risk?YesNo

There is one important technical nuance: some contracts that look like insurance may actually fall within IFRS 9 rather than IFRS 17, depending on their terms and whether significant insurance risk is transferred.

So for your book, a good sentence would be:

“Insurance contracts and derivative contracts both involve uncertainty, but they serve different economic purposes. An insurance contract transfers significant insurance risk, whereas a derivative derives its value from an underlying variable such as a share price, interest rate, currency or commodity price.”


Sunday, November 15, 2026

Belonging: A Journey of Love ~ Sonia Gandhi



Like most reading Indian's current read I too happen to get hold of printed copy of Belonging: A Journey of Love written by Sonia Gandhi and could not stop halfway. It is a very well written autobiography, on her love for her family and country. Both the one she was born into and the one where she eventually belonged. The book will make us reminisce our days during that period. It is intensely readable yet not free of errors. Though the errors would not hinder our reading and I did not find as many as that is being circulated in social media. Vice President K R Narayanan, mentioned as president R K Narayan is a mistake I used to often make and Achan used to correct it. Though Christian von Stieglitz, Amitabh, Narasimha Rao, Bofors, Maneka is all mentioned but nowhere did I read the name of Ottavio Quattrocchi. Did such a person not exist? The book is now circulating as PDF, like her story. A question arise, is it unfortunate or deliberate? 

Was informative to know about the 1957 deadly global pandemic known as the Asian flew and how since then she got the Asthma, how her father had given her a return ticket when she first wanted to visit India and told her that the doors of that house would always be open for her, the sad story of she having lost her first child; comparing Rajeev to Abhimanyu in Mahabharatha, reading and being guided by Bhagavad Gita for her entry into politics. Major part of the book cover Indiraji and Rajivji and latter part include her children and passing reference of her grandchildren.  Her siblings and mother were her constant support until her mother passed away in 2022 at the age of 97 years. 

Loved the structure, flow, most of all the cover page designed by John Gall. Front cover photograph of young Sonia clicked by Rajiv in 1966 and back cover recent picture clicked by her grandson Raihan Vadra and Aviva Baig in 2026. In between them is her story being part of India's political journey. 

Last chapter

 Beyond the Balance Sheet: The Trust Behind the Numbers


Our journey began with something very simple: the need to count.


Long before accounting became a profession, before businesses had balance sheets and before the world spoke of accounting standards, people needed a way to remember what they owned, what they owed and what they exchanged. A few marks on a surface, stones used for counting, and simple records of goods and grain were among the earliest ways in which human beings brought order to their economic lives.


Over centuries, these simple records evolved. Numbers travelled across civilisations, mathematical ideas crossed geographical boundaries, and merchants developed methods to keep track of increasingly complex transactions. Double-entry bookkeeping brought discipline to the recording of business activities. Accounting gradually moved beyond recording transactions to explaining the financial position and performance of an enterprise.


As businesses expanded, so did the responsibilities of those who maintained their accounts. Accounting became a profession, supported by education, examinations, professional institutions and ethical responsibilities. Investors, lenders and governments began depending on financial statements to make decisions. The need for consistency and comparability eventually led to the development of accounting standards.


Yet, the existence of standards did not prevent every failure. Corporate scandals across the world have shown us how financial information can be manipulated, how assets can be overstated, how liabilities can remain hidden and how profits can look impressive even when a business is struggling to generate cash.


These episodes remind us that accounting is not merely about following a prescribed set of rules. It is also about judgement, integrity, transparency and accountability. Standards provide a framework, but people are responsible for applying them honestly.


The world of accounting has continued to change. The handwritten ledger has given way to spreadsheets, enterprise systems, cloud platforms and artificial intelligence. Transactions that once took hours to record and reconcile can now be processed in seconds. Information is available across locations, and finance teams can spend more time analysing business performance rather than simply preparing reports.


But even as technology transforms the profession, its fundamental purpose remains unchanged.


A business may report a profit, but can it generate cash? It may show substantial assets, but do those assets really exist? It may report impressive growth, but is that growth sustainable? These are questions that technology can help us investigate, but they still require human judgement.


For an investor, financial statements are often the closest view of a business that is not directly accessible. For a lender, they provide an understanding of the borrower's financial strength. For employees, they offer clues about the stability of the organisation in which they work. For governments and society, they form part of the information needed to assess economic activity and accountability.


Behind every financial statement, therefore, are people making decisions and people affected by those decisions.


Perhaps that is why accounting deserves to be understood beyond the walls of an accounts department. It is not a language meant only for accountants. It is a language that helps society understand how businesses use resources, create value, manage obligations and remain accountable.


The next time we see a Balance Sheet, we may see a list of assets, liabilities and equity. The Profit and Loss Account may show revenue, expenses and profit. The Cash Flow Statement may explain where the money came from and where it went.


But together, these statements tell a much larger story: the story of a business, the choices it has made, the risks it carries and the promises it must honour.


The numbers may change. The systems may change. The standards may evolve. New technologies may redefine the work of an accountant. But the need for reliable information will remain.


And perhaps that is the greatest lesson from the long journey of accounting: numbers become meaningful only when they can be trusted.


A Balance Sheet may tally. A Trial Balance may agree. Financial statements may comply with every applicable standard. But the real measure of good accounting is whether they faithfully represent the economic reality behind the numbers.


Because, in the end, accounting is not just about getting the numbers right. It is about getting the story right.

Closing lines and Title

 A few possible closing lines

Depending on the emotional note you want to leave with the reader, here are three alternatives.


1. Simple and memorable


"Accounting began with the need to count. It became a profession through the need for accuracy, a discipline through the need for consistency, and a public responsibility through the need for trust."


2. Reflective


"Numbers can be recorded, rearranged, presented and interpreted in many ways. But their true value lies in their ability to tell us what actually happened. That is the responsibility accounting has carried through centuries, and one it must continue to uphold."


3. A little more philosophical


"Long after the ink has faded from the ledgers, the accounting systems have changed and the standards have been rewritten, one expectation will remain: that the numbers we rely upon tell the truth."

My recommendation

I particularly like the last sentence of the main chapter:


"Because, in the end, accounting is not just about getting the numbers right. It is about getting the story right."


It brings together the technical and human sides of your book.


And I would retain the title Beyond the Balance Sheet: The Trust Behind the Numbers. It gives the reader a sense that the book was never just about debits, credits, standards or financial statements. It was about the trust that makes business and commerce possible.


The Trust Behind the Numbers
The Story of Financial Reporting
Meera

Rajesh Exports & Revenue Recognition

 “When the Numbers Lied” or “The Stories Behind the Statements.” Each story would begin with a business that appeared successful, explain what the financial statements showed, reveal what was concealed or misrepresented, and then connect the episode to the accounting or reporting principle that could have helped investors understand the risks.


One important distinction: not every corporate fraud is caused by a failure of accounting standards. Sometimes the standards are adequate but management deliberately falsifies information; sometimes auditors, boards or regulators fail; and sometimes the reporting framework itself has gaps. Your book will be stronger if it helps readers see the difference.

1. Where should the Rajesh Exports story go?

I would include it in a dedicated section towards the end of your chapter on accounting standards and financial reporting, perhaps under the heading:


“When the Numbers Raise Questions: Stories of Financial Reporting Failures”


The case you appear to be referring to is Rajesh Exports, promoted by Rajesh Mehta.


There is an interesting detail worth getting right: the matter reportedly began not with an insider whistleblower, but with a shareholder's complaint to SEBI on 11 March 2024. The complaint questioned large trade receivables that had remained outstanding for years. That seemingly routine accounting concern eventually led to a much wider investigation. 

Company News - Business Standard+1



According to SEBI's interim findings reported in June 2026, the regulator alleged that the company had misrepresented revenue by approximately ₹15.15 lakh crore over the period FY2021–FY2025. The investigation raised questions about overseas subsidiaries, supporting documents, reported sales and transactions. Rajesh Exports disputed the allegations. These are regulatory allegations and interim findings, not something that should be presented as a final judicial finding of guilt. 

Reuters+2



That distinction is especially important in a book. I would call it “The Shareholder Who Questioned the Receivables”, rather than “The Rajesh Exports Gold Scam”.

2. How to tell it as a story

The strength of this case is that it begins with an ordinary accounting item: trade receivables.


Here is how I would write it in the style of your book.

The Shareholder Who Questioned the Receivables

Sometimes, a major financial investigation does not begin with a dramatic discovery. It begins with a simple question.


In March 2024, a shareholder of Rajesh Exports, one of India's prominent gold refining and jewellery companies, approached the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) with a concern. The issue was not initially about gold reserves, manufacturing capacity or the company's impressive business operations. It was about something that appears in almost every company's Balance Sheet: trade receivables.


Trade receivables represent money that customers owe a business for goods or services already supplied. In an ordinary business, credit sales are a routine part of operations. A company sells its products, raises an invoice and waits for the customer to pay. The amount due is recorded as a receivable.


But what happens when the money does not arrive for months, or even years?


A growing receivables balance may indicate that a company is extending more credit to customers. It may also point to delayed collections, disputes, doubtful debts or, in some circumstances, questions about whether the underlying sales were genuine.


The shareholder's complaint raised concerns about large receivables that had remained outstanding for an extended period. What appeared to be a question about collections eventually prompted a much wider examination of the company's financial reporting.


SEBI's investigation brought the company's reported revenues, overseas operations, subsidiary transactions and supporting documentation under scrutiny. The regulator's interim findings in June 2026 raised serious questions about the scale and verifiability of revenues reported over several financial years.


The figures involved were extraordinary. SEBI alleged revenue misrepresentation of approximately ₹15.15 lakh crore between FY2021 and FY2025. Questions were also raised about transactions involving overseas entities and the availability of records to substantiate the reported business activity.


The company disputed the allegations. The matter therefore needs to be understood in the context of the regulator's interim proceedings and the company's response, rather than treated as a concluded finding.


But the story offers an important lesson even before the final outcome is known.


A sale recorded in the books is not necessarily proof that the money will be collected. Revenue reported in a financial statement must be supported by an underlying transaction. The goods or services must have been supplied, the customer relationship must be genuine, and the accounting treatment must reflect the substance of what actually happened.


This is why financial reporting cannot stop at the Profit and Loss Account. The Balance Sheet, cash flow statement, notes to accounts and disclosures must be read together.


A company may report impressive revenue and profits, but investors should also ask: How much cash has the business generated? How much money remains to be collected? Who owes the company this money? How old are the receivables? Are the transactions supported by reliable documentation?


The question raised by one shareholder illustrates the importance of looking beyond headline revenue and profit figures.


Sometimes, the most important warning sign in a company's financial statements is not a dramatic loss or a sudden fall in sales. It is an amount that has remained unexplained for far too long.

The accounting lessons you can draw from this story include revenue recognition, the existence and recoverability of receivables, consolidation of subsidiaries, related-party transactions, supporting documentation and the importance of cash-flow information. It also raises questions about audit evidence and regulatory oversight.

Format

 Other stories that would make excellent chapters or case studies

I would select stories from different countries and periods. Each illustrates a different weakness in financial reporting. The reader would gradually understand why accounting standards, disclosures, independent audits and corporate governance matter.



1. Satyam Computer Services – The cash that did not exist

Essential Indian case study

In January 2009, chairman B. Ramalinga Raju admitted that Satyam's accounts contained inflated cash and bank balances, fictitious accrued interest, understated liabilities and overstated debtors.


Accounting lesson: Bank confirmations, existence of assets, audit evidence, revenue and profit reliability, internal controls.


A powerful Indian example of how a balance sheet can look healthy while the underlying financial position is very different. 

BSE India+1




2. Enron – The company that hid its debts


The American energy giant used complex special-purpose entities and accounting arrangements to keep certain debts and losses away from its reported balance sheet.


Accounting lesson: Consolidation, control, related-party disclosures, substance over form and off-balance-sheet arrangements.


This is an excellent story for explaining why the financial statements of a group must reflect the economic reality of entities it controls. 

SEC+1




3. Wirecard – The missing €1.9 billion


The German payments company reported substantial cash balances that could not be verified. In 2020, the company disclosed that €1.9 billion supposedly held in trustee accounts probably did not exist.


Accounting lesson: Cash and bank balance verification, audit independence, confirmation procedures, auditor responsibility and regulatory supervision.


This is particularly useful because it shows that even sophisticated financial reporting systems and large audit firms cannot eliminate the need for professional scepticism. 

ESMA+1




4. Carillion – Profits on paper, collapse in reality


The British construction and services company collapsed in January 2018. Its reported financial strength had concealed serious problems involving contracts, debt, cash flows and pension obligations.


Accounting lesson: Revenue recognition, contract accounting, provisions, liabilities, going concern and cash-flow reporting.


The British parliamentary inquiry is particularly useful for understanding the gap between reported profits and the financial health of a business. 

House of Commons+2




5. Toshiba – The pressure to show profits


In 2015, Toshiba acknowledged inappropriate accounting practices involving the recognition of profits, including long-term infrastructure projects. An independent investigation examined how management pressure contributed to the problem.


Accounting lesson: Percentage-of-completion accounting, revenue recognition, estimates, management override and corporate governance.


This case is useful for showing how pressure to meet profit targets can influence accounting judgements. 

global.toshiba



4. Other stories worth considering

There are several more cases that could enrich the book:

Company / case What makes it interesting Accounting connection

Parmalat (Italy) A supposedly large bank deposit turned out to be fictitious. Cash verification, audit evidence, consolidation

Luckin Coffee (China) Fabricated sales and revenue figures. Revenue recognition, internal controls

Nirav Modi / PNB (India) Fraudulent bank guarantees and weaknesses in banking controls. Contingent liabilities, disclosures, internal controls

DHFL (India) Complex lending, related-party transactions and questions about financial reporting. Financial assets, impairment, related parties

IL&FS (India) A major infrastructure group defaulted despite its earlier reputation and ratings. Consolidation, liquidity, debt, going concern


I would use Parmalat, Luckin Coffee and PNB as supporting examples rather than giving every case a full chapter. They broaden the reader's understanding of the different ways financial information can become unreliable.

5. How to organise these stories in your book

Rather than placing all the fraud cases together as a catalogue, I would organise them around the accounting questions they raise.

Part I – The numbers that misled investors

- Satyam – Where did the cash go?

- Rajesh Exports – Why were the receivables not being collected?

- Luckin Coffee – Were the sales real?


Part II – What the Balance Sheet did not reveal

- Enron – Where were the debts?

- Parmalat – Did the cash exist?

- DHFL – What was happening behind the lending figures?


Part III – When profits concealed the problem

- Carillion – How healthy was the business really?

- Toshiba – Were the profits recognised too early?

- Wirecard – Who verified the cash?


Part IV – The lessons for investors and the profession

- The importance of financial statement disclosures.

- The responsibility of auditors and directors.

- The role of regulators and standard setters.

- Why investors must read beyond the Profit and Loss Account.


6. A common storytelling format for every case

I suggest following the same five-part structure for each story:

1. The promise: What did the company look like to investors? What made it attractive?

2. The numbers: What did its financial statements report?

3. The warning sign: What first raised questions? Who noticed it?

4. The discovery: What did investigations reveal, and what remains disputed?

5. The accounting lesson: Which accounting principle, disclosure requirement, audit procedure or governance mechanism does the case help us understand?

This will make the book accessible to readers who have never studied accounting.


For example, after telling the Satyam story, you could explain what a bank confirmation is and why an auditor cannot simply rely on a bank balance appearing in the company's ledger.


After Enron, you could explain why a subsidiary or special-purpose entity may need to be consolidated even when its legal structure appears separate.


After Carillion, you could explain why profit is not the same as cash and why the going-concern assumption matters.


One important thought for the book: Do not make it a book about corporate scandals alone. Make it a book about why trustworthy financial reporting matters. For every story of failure, explain the accounting principle that exists to protect the reader of the financial statements.


I would even consider opening this section with a simple question:


If a company reports a profit of ₹1,000 crore, how do we know that it has actually earned it? If it reports cash of ₹5,000 crore, how do we know that the money is really in the bank? And if it reports phenomenal growth, how do we know that the business behind those numbers exists?


Those three questions could take your reader through the entire world of accounting standards and financial reporting.

Stories and structure

 More unusual stories that readers may find fascinating

These are particularly good because they illustrate different accounting principles, rather than repeating the same type of fraud.

1. Olympus – The CEO who questioned the books


In 2011, newly appointed British CEO Michael Woodford questioned unusual payments associated with acquisitions. His investigation helped expose a long-running scheme to conceal investment losses.


Lesson: Goodwill, acquisition accounting, impairment, board accountability and whistleblower protection. 

The Guardian

2. WorldCom – When expenses became assets


The company classified ordinary operating expenses, including network costs, as capital expenditure. This made current profits look higher because the costs were spread over future periods.


Lesson: Capital expenditure versus revenue expenditure, asset recognition and depreciation. 

Banca d'Italia+1

3. Lehman Brothers – The disappearing debt


The investment bank used transactions known as Repo 105 to temporarily reduce reported balance-sheet leverage around reporting dates.


Lesson: Substance over form, financial liabilities, temporary balance-sheet arrangements and disclosure. 

my.liuc.it+1


4. Tesco – Profits recognised before they were earned


The retailer overstated its expected profits by recognising supplier income too early and making incorrect accrual estimates.


Lesson: Accrual accounting, estimates, cut-off and revenue recognition. 

The Guardian+1

5. Bernie Madoff – The investment statements that were fiction


Madoff operated a massive Ponzi scheme, presenting investors with fictitious returns and account statements.


Lesson: Independent verification of assets, custody of investments, third-party confirmations and the limits of audit assurance. This is an investment fraud rather than a conventional corporate financial-reporting scandal, which makes it a useful contrast.


6. Coffee Day Enterprises – Where did the money go?


Investigations into the company raised questions about loans and fund transfers involving promoter-linked entities and the recoverability of amounts due.


Lesson: Related-party transactions, recoverability, internal controls, audit evidence and consolidation. NFRA's findings on audit failures make this a particularly relevant Indian case. 

ETCFO.com


7. IndusInd Bank – The problem hidden in derivatives


In 2025, the bank disclosed accounting discrepancies involving internal derivative trades that affected its reported net worth. A subsequent forensic review raised questions about documentation and controls.


Lesson: Derivative accounting, fair value, financial instruments, internal controls and timely disclosure. 

Reuters


6. My recommended shortlist for your book

You do not need to include every scandal. Too many similar stories could make the book repetitive. I would choose around 10–12 substantial case studies, with a balance of Indian and international examples.

Priority Story Principle to explain

1 Satyam Cash verification and audit evidence

2 Enron Consolidation and hidden liabilities

3 WorldCom Capitalisation of expenses

4 Rajesh Exports Revenue and receivables

5 Wirecard Bank confirmations and auditor independence

6 Carillion Going concern and cash flow

7 Olympus Acquisitions and concealed losses

8 Kingfisher Airlines Lease accounting and expense recognition

9 Parmalat Fictitious cash balances

10 Toshiba Management pressure and estimates

11 IL&FS Governance, debt and liquidity

12 Coffee Day Enterprises Related-party transactions and audit quality


7. An idea that could make your book distinctive

Alongside the scandal stories, I would include a few stories where accounting standards made a positive difference.


For example:

- Lease accounting: Why IFRS 16 and Ind AS 116 changed the way companies report leases. An airline or retailer can be a useful illustration.

- Revenue recognition: Why IFRS 15 and Ind AS 115 require companies to recognise revenue when performance obligations are satisfied, rather than simply when invoices are raised.

- Financial instruments: Why IFRS 9 and Ind AS 109 introduced an expected-credit-loss approach instead of waiting until a loan had actually defaulted.

- Fair value: Why IFRS 13 and Ind AS 113 provide a framework for measuring assets and liabilities when market values are not readily observable.

These would give the book balance: not just stories of how reporting went wrong, but examples of how standards help investors understand businesses better.


My strongest recommendation: Give each case study a memorable title, tell the story in two or three pages, and end with a small section called “What the Numbers Should Have Told Us.” That recurring feature could become the signature of your book.


I would also maintain a source file for each case, using regulator orders, investigation reports, court judgments and company disclosures wherever possible. This is particularly important when allegations are still disputed or proceedings are ongoing.

Accounting in Transition: From Ledgers to Intelligent Finance



Accounting in Transition: From Ledgers to Intelligent Finance


Three decades ago, we celebrated when the Trial Balance tallied and the Balance Sheet balanced. Journal entries were written manually, posted into ledgers, and then brought together to prepare the Trial Balance and the financial statements. Every stage required patience, attention to detail and a fair amount of arithmetic.


The accounting office of those days was usually filled with books, papers, files and, quite often, dust. The calculator was an accountant's constant companion, and a well-maintained ledger was a matter of pride.


The generation entering the profession today may never have experienced this routine. They may know what a Trial Balance is from their accounting textbooks, but may not have had to prepare one manually or understand the satisfaction of seeing the debits and credits tally after hours of work.


Technology gradually changed this world. As computers became commonplace and Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) systems were introduced, many accounting activities began to be automated. The piles of books and papers started disappearing, and offices moved towards becoming partially paperless.


Systems such as JD Edwards, SAP, Oracle and PeopleSoft brought several business and accounting activities onto integrated platforms. Data management and consolidation tools such as Hyperion, along with reporting and analytical tools such as Cognos and Essbase, made it possible to store, consolidate and interpret large volumes of financial information.


The impact went beyond making accounting faster. Technology made it possible to move activities away from individual business units and bring them together at a central location. As businesses expanded across countries and continents, this centralisation became increasingly attractive. It was one of the developments that gave rise to the Shared Services Centre.


1. The Rise of Shared Services


In the early days, the primary objective of establishing a Shared Services Centre (SSC) was cost reduction. Instead of maintaining separate finance and administrative teams in every business unit, organisations could consolidate similar activities at a common location, share resources and reduce duplication.


Over time, however, the purpose of shared services evolved. Cost reduction remained important, but the expectation shifted towards creating a best-in-class service organisation within the company. The SSC was no longer expected merely to process transactions. It was expected to improve processes, introduce automation, strengthen controls, provide meaningful information and eventually become a strategic partner to the business.


The evolution of a Shared Services Centre can be viewed in three broad phases.


Phase I – Set-up and Stabilisation


The first one to two years are generally devoted to establishing the centre and stabilising operations. Activities previously performed by different business units are transferred to the central team. Processes are documented, responsibilities are assigned, employees are trained and service expectations are established.


The initial savings come largely from consolidating resources, reducing duplication, optimising office space and allowing employees to handle a wider range of activities. Depending on the organisation and the processes being transferred, this phase can deliver meaningful cost savings.


The challenge during this period is to ensure that the transition does not compromise the quality or timeliness of services. A process that has been moved from one location to another is not necessarily an improved process. Stabilisation must therefore be accompanied by clear procedures, proper training and effective controls.


Phase II – Development and Improvement


Once operations have stabilised, the centre can focus on improving the way work is performed. This phase may extend from the third to the sixth year, although the pace of development differs from one organisation to another.


The emphasis moves from simply completing transactions to understanding the processes behind them. Teams begin identifying inefficiencies, eliminating unnecessary steps, standardising activities and sharing best practices across business units.


The growing volume of data also creates new opportunities. Information that was earlier used mainly for accounting and reporting can now support business decisions. Spend analytics, supplier grouping, procurement analysis and working-capital monitoring can help organisations identify savings and improve coordination between business units.


Productivity improves, controls become stronger and risks can be identified earlier. The SSC begins to contribute not only through the services it delivers but also through the insights it provides.


Phase III – World-Class Operations


In a more mature phase, the Shared Services Centre aspires to operate at a world-class level. Automation, digitisation and process integration become central to its functioning.


Performance is monitored through real-time dashboards and clearly defined Service Level Agreements (SLAs). These agreements establish measurable expectations for service quality, accuracy, timeliness and productivity. The centre is expected to demonstrate how its contribution supports the wider objectives of the organisation.


At this stage, an SSC may serve business units across several countries, support multiple functions and operate on a global scale. Digital workflows reduce paper-based processing, while Robotic Process Automation (RPA) takes over repetitive, rule-based activities.


Some mature centres also explore opportunities to provide services to external organisations or operate as separate business entities. The ultimate ambition is to move beyond being a cost centre and become a source of operational excellence and business value.


The journey from a cost-saving centre to a strategic finance partner is not automatic. It requires investment in technology, people, process improvement and leadership. But it demonstrates how accounting operations have gradually moved from recording transactions to supporting business performance.


2. Outsourcing: The Make-or-Buy Decision


As technology improved and businesses expanded, organisations began asking another important question: should every activity be performed within the company, or would it be more effective to engage an external specialist?


This is the familiar make-or-buy decision.


The choice involves comparing the relevant costs, capabilities and risks of performing an activity in-house with those of outsourcing it. Organisations may outsource activities that are specialised, technology-intensive or peripheral to their core business. This allows internal teams to concentrate on activities that are more closely connected to business strategy and revenue generation.


The finance and accounting function has also been part of this transformation. Global service providers now support organisations with technology implementation, process transformation, change management and several finance activities. These services may be delivered onshore, offshore or through a combination of locations.


Activities such as accounts payable, accounts receivable, reconciliations, transaction processing and even aspects of financial reporting can be supported by external service providers. With clearly defined responsibilities, appropriate technology and effective oversight, outsourcing can improve efficiency, consistency and the timeliness of financial close.


However, outsourcing is not without its challenges. Organisations may become dependent on external providers and lose some of the process knowledge that was earlier available internally. Confidentiality and data security need careful attention. There may also be concerns about quality, flexibility, control and the ability to respond quickly to changing business requirements.


The decision should therefore not be based on cost alone. Organisations must consider the strategic importance of the activity, the sensitivity of the information involved, the availability of internal expertise and the risks of transferring responsibility to another party.


The objective is not to outsource everything that can be outsourced. It is to identify where external expertise can create greater value while ensuring that the organisation retains sufficient knowledge and control over its critical processes.


3. Technology: From Automation to Intelligence


The role of the finance function has changed considerably. Traditionally, much of its time was spent recording transactions, reconciling accounts, preparing reports and ensuring that the books were closed accurately and on time.


Today, boards and business leaders expect much more from finance. The Chief Financial Officer is increasingly expected to be a strategic partner who supports business growth, evaluates investment decisions, manages risks and helps the organisation navigate uncertainty.


Mergers and acquisitions, changing markets, regulatory developments, currency movements and technological disruption have made business decisions more complex. The finance team is expected not only to explain what has happened but also to provide insights into what may happen next.


Digital technology and analytics have made this possible. Business process automation, robotics, machine learning and artificial intelligence are changing the way financial information is collected, processed and interpreted.


Robotic Process Automation, for example, is particularly useful for repetitive activities that follow clearly defined rules. Matching supplier invoices with purchase orders and goods receipts, transferring information between systems and performing routine reconciliations are examples of tasks that can be automated.


But not every transaction follows a predictable pattern. An invoice may contain an unusual charge, a supplier's details may not match the master data, or a transaction may require judgement before it can be processed. This is where more advanced technologies, including artificial intelligence, can assist.


AI can analyse large volumes of structured and unstructured data, identify patterns, highlight unusual transactions and bring together information that might otherwise remain unnoticed. In accounts payable, for instance, it can help identify invoice exceptions and prioritise items that require human attention.


This is sometimes described as augmented intelligence: the combination of human judgement and machine capability. Rather than replacing the finance professional, technology can take over much of the repetitive work and allow people to focus on interpretation, problem-solving and decision-making.


The real value lies in combining the strengths of both. Machines can process information at a scale and speed that would be difficult for individuals to match. People bring context, experience, professional judgement and an understanding of the wider business.


However, the quality of the output depends on the quality of the information being used. Organisations need reliable data, consistent definitions and well-maintained systems. A centralised data foundation can help different functions work with the same information, but it also requires sound data governance, data engineering and master data management.


There are risks too. Artificial intelligence can reproduce biases present in the data on which it has been trained or in the assumptions made by those who design and use it. For example, an automated system supporting customer credit decisions may produce unfair outcomes if its underlying data or decision rules are biased.


The use of AI therefore calls for accountability, transparency and human oversight. Technology may provide a recommendation, but organisations must still understand how that recommendation was reached and whether it is appropriate.


This changing environment also calls for a different combination of skills within finance teams. Accounting and industry knowledge remain essential, but professionals increasingly need to understand analytics, forecasting, data management and technology. Skills such as design thinking, problem-solving and the ability to work across functions are becoming equally valuable.


The finance professional of the future may not spend most of the day entering transactions or preparing spreadsheets. Instead, the role may involve questioning the numbers, understanding the trends, evaluating risks and helping management make better decisions.


4. The Cloud and the Changing Workplace


Technology has also changed where and how finance teams work. Earlier, financial information was often stored in separate systems, and accessing it could involve multiple reports, spreadsheets and manual consolidations.


Cloud-based platforms have made it possible to access information from different locations and devices, subject to appropriate security and access controls. They can also bring together information from different functions, allowing finance teams to connect financial data with operational and human-resource information.


Platforms such as Workday Financial Management illustrate this shift towards integrated cloud-based systems. Instead of maintaining several disconnected applications for different activities, organisations can bring many processes onto a common platform.


However, implementing a large financial system is a significant investment. The benefits do not come merely from purchasing the technology. They depend on how well the system is designed, implemented and adopted by the people who use it.


Four considerations are particularly important.


First, plan for value from the beginning. Organisations should identify the benefits they expect from the investment before implementation begins. Faster reporting, fewer manual interventions, better controls and improved visibility should be translated into measurable outcomes. The business case should not be an afterthought.


Second, align the platform with business needs. Technology should support the organisation's operating model, reporting requirements and control environment. A powerful system will not deliver its full potential if it is designed without understanding the needs of the business and the capabilities of its users.


Third, focus on implementation and adoption. The objective should be to make the system operational within a realistic timeframe while ensuring that employees are trained and processes are properly tested. Speed matters, but not at the cost of accuracy, security or control.


Fourth, invest in the right people and expertise. No organisation has every skill it needs at all times. External specialists can help bridge technology and implementation gaps, while internal employees need opportunities to develop their capabilities. The aim should be to combine external expertise with internal knowledge rather than become permanently dependent on either.


Even within a platform such as Workday, tools are available to make data movement and integration easier. One example is the Enterprise Interface Builder (EIB).


EIB is a configuration-based tool that allows users to create inbound and outbound integrations without necessarily writing complex code. An outbound EIB extracts information from Workday and sends it to another destination. An inbound EIB brings information into Workday, often using structured templates such as spreadsheets. Depending on the integration, these processes may involve file transfers, cloud connections or other supporting services.


Such tools make it easier to exchange information between systems, although more complex integrations may still require technical expertise and third-party support.


The spreadsheet, once an accountant's most trusted companion, has not disappeared. Macros and other spreadsheet-based tools continue to be useful. But many activities that once required extensive manual work can now be performed through integrated systems and automated workflows.


The cloud has also changed the experience of accessing financial information. Reports can be viewed remotely, information can be shared across locations and finance teams can work with colleagues around the world. The integration of finance with functions such as human resources and procurement provides a more complete picture of the organisation.


The aspiration is simple: fewer disconnected systems, less repetitive data entry, better access to reliable information and more time for meaningful analysis.


The days of spending sleepless nights trying to make the Balance Sheet tally may not have disappeared entirely, but technology has certainly changed the nature of the work.


5. The Accountant in the New World


From handwritten ledgers to ERP systems, from local accounting offices to global shared services, and from manual reconciliations to artificial intelligence, the journey has been remarkable.


Yet one thing has not changed: the need for reliable financial information and sound judgement.


Technology can record, process, consolidate and analyse information. It can identify patterns and draw attention to exceptions. But it is still the responsibility of finance professionals to understand the business behind the numbers, question unusual results, exercise judgement and ensure that information is presented fairly.


The accountant's role is therefore not becoming less important. It is changing.


The profession is moving from a largely transaction-oriented function towards one that combines accounting knowledge, technology, analytics and business understanding. The tools may change, the workplace may look different, and the speed at which information is processed may be extraordinary. But the underlying responsibility remains the same: to make financial information meaningful, dependable and useful.


Perhaps the greatest transformation in accounting is not that machines can now do much of the work that people once did. It is that accountants have an opportunity to spend less time preparing numbers and more time understanding what those numbers mean.