Tuesday, December 31, 2019

2019 - Another Year - Eventful




Eventful, indeed was the year. Even comman men have started taking interest in politics/economics. Constitution is being read and understood. Some Significant Dates which will help navigate the year are:

1st January 2019 - In a first, over 35 lakh women stood shoulder-to-shoulder across the national highways in Kerala, creating a 620 km-long human 'wall' from the northern end of Kasaragod to the southern tip as part of a state-sponsored initiative to uphold gender equality. The 'Women's wall' was conceived in the backdrop of frenzied protests witnessed in the hill shrine of Lord Ayyappa at Sabarimala after the CPI(M)-led LDF government decided to implement the Supreme Court verdict, allowing all women to pray at the Ayyappa shrine. This was against the judgement by Supreme Court in September 2018 stating women are equally entitled to have entry to public space. For some the protest was like the Stockholm syndrome.


14th February Pulwama attack; one of the deadliest terror attacks in Jammu and Kashmir. 40 Central Reserve Police Force (CRPF) personnel were martyred. a convoy of vehicles carrying security personnel on the Jammu Srinagar National Highway was attacked by a vehicle-borne suicide bomber at Lethpora. The attacker was identified to be Adil Ahmad Dar, a local from Pulwama district, and a member of Jaish-e-Mohammed.


26th February, Tuesday - Balakot airstrike was conducted by India in the early morning hours when Indian warplanes crossed the de facto border in the disputed region of Kashmir, and dropped bombs in the vicinity of the town of Balakot in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa province in Pakistan. Request for restraint was made by Australia, China, US, France and Organisation of Islamic Cooperation. The PAF downed a MiG-21 Bison in an aerial combat, after Varthaman had shot down an F-16 of Pakistan. IAF Wing Commander pilot Abhinandan Varthaman was captured, who was handed over to India on March 1.

27 March 2019, India tested an anti-satellite weapon during an operation code named Mission Shakti (IAST; Śakti lit. "Power"). The target of the test was a satellite present in a low Earth orbit, which was hit with a kinetic kill vehicle.

23rd May 2019, Modi was reelected as the Prime Minister of India with a sweeping majority, The success of Modi 1.0 was the on ground implementation of various schemes like Swatch bharat, Ujvala, Jandhan, DBT, PM Hosing, Digital India, Mudra Loans etc. clubbed with strategies by Amit Modi Jodi, BJP is firmly in saddle, with the Congress completely decimated with A catchy slogan:'Aab Ki Baar Modi Sarkar' (Not BJP but Modi-Shah Jodi Sarkar), The usage of IT and social media to reach out to the mass, converted this election into a US presidential model, where his opponents were pushed to talking only about him, good or bad, and that publicity helped. Also seems voting machines had a part to play in the results. BJP's indulgence in horse trading to execute this installment of Operation Lotus cannot be ruled out.

23rd July 2019, Chandrayaan-2 the spacecraft was launched on its mission to the Moon from the second launch pad at the Satish Dhawan Space Centre by a GSLV Mark III. The craft reached the Moon's orbit on 20 August 2019 and began orbital positioning manoeuvres for the landing of the Vikram lander. However, the lander deviated from its intended trajectory starting at 2.1 kilometres (1.3 mi) altitude, and had lost communication when touchdown confirmation was expected. Initial reports suggesting a crash[30][31] were confirmed by ISRO chairman K. Sivan, stating that "it must have been a hard landing". The Failure Analysis Committee concluded that the crash was caused by a software glitch.

30th July 2019, Thriple Thalaq bill was passed declaring the practice of Triple Talaq as illegal, unconstitutional and made it punishable act from 1 August 2019 which is deemed to be in effect from 19 September 2018.

5th August 2019, Article 370 providing special status to the state of Jammu and Kashmir was withdrawn. "I was waiting to see this day in my lifetime." Sushma Swaraj Tweeted this and within hours had her last breath. August was the month of deaths - Starting with the 'Cafe Cofee Day - Siddartha's Suicide; Death of Sushma Swaraj to my deal Mother in Law and Sid's mother.

22 September Narendra Modi addressed "Shared Dreams, Bright Futures", Texas India Forum.2 power-soaked megalomaniacs met each other's match at Houstan while 50k cheered on and 20 k protested outside. This clearly tells us a good bit about the power of critical thinking and how each think the other to be bigots and hypocrites. Many stood with pride out in the sun, drenched in honest sweat, outside the NRG stadium, in Houston, with prefabricated posters, T-shirts, flags, etc. which they believed to be the moral side of history, while the another lot danced to the tunes of the megalomaniacs inside the opulence of the NRG stadium.



9th Nov 2019 finally decision was made on Ayodhya dispute. The Supreme Court, in a 1,045-page, unanimous verdict by a five-judge constitution bench comprising Chief Justice of India Ranjan Gogoi, brought closure to the case, one community ended up with the 'site' and the other with a five-acre plot not by virtue of being the majority and minority nor because of faith, but because the apex court unambiguously believes in the evidence of 'actual worship down the centuries'. The reasoning, according to the learned judges, was that while both parties Ram Lalla Virajman and the Sunni Central Waqf Board had competing rights over the disputed site, lawyers representing the Hindus had provided better evidence of continuous worship compared to the Muslims. Critics argue that judgement was relied on "faith instead of law and reason" and that the judgment has "sided with majoritarianism".

11th Dec 2019 CAB was passed in parliament. This is not anything new - Upto Article 15 of the Constitution, already covered it - But the year ended with unrest about it; presumably because:
1) Ethnicity of people in states like Assam was being effected
2) Some linked it to NRC, which was done in Assam and yet to be implemented in the rest of the country - and saw the danger of the minority being persecuted
3) Politicians made it a religious issue for the reasons best known
4) Haste in passing the bill, without explaining and bringing the minority into confidence


My thought - rather than making the 'bill - presently passed' so complicated - why could they not just have included in the amendment clause - 'Includes' - minorities of neighboring countries; and minority 'means' - anyone who is not the major population of that country and constitute say 5% of the population of that country?

By the end of the year the State Election results have shown that, India is firmly back to being a federal constitutional entity – The politics of the state is challenging the politics of the centre; which had strong majority of the same party for some time. People started making distinction between national and state. Our PM is a leader by himself – but not all powerful a popular leader – i.e. he cannot win lamp post state election. Poli - Tricks was seen in many state elections and how all efforts were made to keep the seats like in Karnataka, Maharashtra which are different stories by themselves - interesting ones. After 11 days of presidents rule, when the news papers had morning headlines on 23rd November - that NCP/Sena/Congress would form a collision government in Maharashtra; the news in the web media read the Devendra Fadnavis had swron in as CM in the wee hours of the morning. He was in office for three days - what was the real agenda behind that? Then followed a week of interesting drama.

14th July 2019 though England had lost early wickets, B Strokes kept the game going. Towards end New Zealand had missed catches, catch becoming six, and a two becoming four which eventually turned to six, all pointing towards a lucky day for England and the match ending in a tie of 241 each. Now it was time for Super Over. 6 balls per team. Six balls or two wickets whichever is earlier finishes the super over. England Scored 15 runs with batting continued by Stokes and Buttler. Neesham and N Guptil from NZ took over. And here too there was a tie, with Guptil being run out on the last ball!! England became champions based on number of boundaries. England scored 26 boundaries in total in the entire duration of the match as compared to 17 by the Black Caps and were thus crowned as champions, winning the world cup cricket. Indeed hard luck for New Zealand. Men in Blue were toppers through out, but was chucked out in the Semifinals.

Other highlights in sports were National record holder Dutee Chand became the first Indian woman track and field athlete to clinch a gold medal at the 30th Summer University Games in Napoli, Italy after she won the 100m dash event in July this year; Hima Das, who won five successive gold medals in different meets across Poland and the Czech Republic in July within 20 days. Four of her victories came in the 200m sprint while her fifth top-podium finish was in the 400m event; PV Sindhu on August 25 became the first Indian to win gold in BWF World Badminton Championships by beating familiar rival Nozomi Okuhara of Japan in a lop-sided final in Basel; Para-badminton player Manasi Joshi also created history by securing gold at the BWF Para-Badminton World Championships, just a day before Sindhu; India's middle-distance runner PU Chitra ran her season's best to win the women's 1500m gold at the Folksam Grand Prix in Sweden in June after winning the gold in the Asian Championships in April.

Indian-American Abhijit Banerjee, his wife Esther Duflo and Michael Kremer jointly won the 2019 Nobel Economics Prize on a Monday, 14th October "for their experimental approach to alleviating global poverty."

On the last Monday of the year - 30th December India gets her first Chief of defence staff, General Bipin Rawat, the senior-most uniformed military adviser to the Government of India. .. The Chief of Defence Staff (CDS) is the professional tri-service chief of the Indian Armed Forces and ill serve as the first CDS till December 2022, coordinating the army, navy and airforce.


Amdist all these Paul Salopek in his Year 6 of a Global Journalism Journey - On his 'out of Eden' walk across the planet that bridges continents, languages, nationalities and creeds was in India covering around 1,800 miles including the banks of Ganga and Brahmaputra; naming his Chapter 'Riverlands' and exploring the mounting effects of dramatic environmental change, including climate woes, rapid urbanization, growing communal tensions in the world’s largest democracy, and the tenuous endurance of South Asia’s many varied cultures.

Stand up performance was not just from Shashi Tharoor in One Mic stand; but from the actor parliamentarian Smriti Irani. Remember her Rohit Vemula lies and 'Satya Meva Jayate' speech full of lies? She outdid herself again by twisting a statement by Rahul Gandhi to interpret it as a 'Clarion Call' to 'Rape in India'. All because they wanted to kill another debate on North East, CAA, NRC and Kashmir. And the entire BJP MP's, without morality, responsibility or principles, disrupted parliament. Here was a ruling party disrupting parliament; though there were two long sessions and many bills passed this year. Then we had the duo giving us hearty laugh...Gaurav Vallabh and Sambit Patra.

Each day brings new horrors of depravity against women! You think it can't get worse..but it does! While Nirbhaya's Delhi High Court hearing is adjourned - Tarikh pe tarikh. Tarikh pe tarikh, Are we waiting for shashtipurthi of culprits? there are new cases sprouting across the countries - with poor victims burned to death, and poor criminal's being shot - while rich criminal's still moving around being MP's and MLA's.

Need of the hour:

Stop talking of how many woman were raped, but say how many men raped women;
Stop saying how many police saved victims or killed culprits, but say how many police prevented possibilities;
Stop discriminating and murdering our constitution, but uphold and protect it;
Stop passing bills like Citizenship Amendment Act, but pass bills like politicians amendment act - restricting entry for criminals in parliament;
Stop attacking on people having different views, accept the differences, patience - tolerance pays;
Stop arriving at a 'perfect conclusion' reached at by majority creating discord, agree for an imperfect decision arrived at by consensus leading to harmony;

" Those of us whose faith in India’s democratic system was absolute now face the sobering realisation that its roots may be shallower than we had allowed ourselves to believe"

Indian government must create an atmosphere of trust to improve consumer/society/economy/mass sentiments. Social reforms and changes are also needed, but has to be properly planned and prioritized. For the year end protests Government also has their share for not being able to foresee and for being in a hurry...what people say is home ministry is in a home delivery spree. Either other departments should come to his speed or he should slow down. How would it be if only one tire of your car go in super speed? All can see, what it is to be misruled. We did need doers, we did have hare and tortise in the past, but seems now is the time for Cheetah. The actions of the Government do determine, the direction, that they are heading towards.

Climatic change has been impacted like never before with India going through an unprecedented natural disaster with eight states experiencing heavy to very heavy rains for days, including neighboring countries, while few other states had almost near drought, and few states have highest winter in 120 years. Unemployment is at its highest in the near past. 12 of the worlds 15 most polluted cities are in India, poverty, malnourishment, falling living standard, agriculture distress, middle-class distress, increasing gap between rich & poor continue to be daily issues.

Environmental system includes - strengthen economic, political and social security - which can be strengthened with strong laws, powerful system and ethics. This can happen with radical leadership. So Environmental problem today is no more confined to Air, Water, or Sound pollution. Need is to save democracy, which have a huge say in the investments. Give priority to people and planet and not profit or religion. Cataract continues to be the third biggest cause of blindness, religion and politics remaining the first two. It's so interesting to see for one same event/situation/decision required some like, some love, some cry and some are angry about it. That's life. Nothing is completely right. It all depend on the time, situation, mood, thoughts and surroundings of the person.

When it comes to rulers—or their Dewans—who can change the lives of an entire population, small acts have huge consequences. Our mistakes may not matter to anyone; theirs could cost a great deal.

People make history. You and I, and everyone around us, are shaping history in our own microscopic ways. Our actions are affected by normal human feelings like jealousy, ego, helplessness, arrogance, love, kindness and so forth.

Hope in the coming year we become better - than who, how and where we are today!

Sathyameva Jayathe!



Monday, December 30, 2019

Flying High - A dozen Formidable success stories By R Sivakumar & V Pattabhi Ram


An amazing, thought provoking and value adding insights from lives of men united in profession and proving how diverse and enriching the career paths can be. As Justice Prabha Sridevan mention in the Forward - "This is a very well-written book. Meticulous, humane with touches of humour, while underlining the strong ethical core inside each of the men covered. " "Congratulate the authors for their labour of love" The chapter on 5 lessons from their lives, summaries what we can draw from these 12 outstanding men. Can't Thank You enough R Sivakumar Sir and Pattabhi Ram Sir the 2 Gems who write about the 12 gems.

Really missed S Gurumurthy as rightly mentioned in From the Editors - This is 'a' list and not 'the' list. So expecting more as sequel or series. Each chapter has brief bio, beautiful pictures, and above all lessons from each of them and the one that resonates and apt for the current political situation is that by GN " Finally, an imperfect decision arrived at by consensus is better than a perfect 'conclusion' reached at by majority."

Wednesday, December 25, 2019

The Arthashastra - Kautilya



Chanakya/Kautilya and Machiavelli both gave most profound and most practised philosophies of Statecraft, Governance and International Politics. Chanakya who lived many centuries before Machiavelli has entered Indian vocabulary as the equivalent of 'Machiavellian' . While Machiavelli wrote ‘The Prince’ for Lorenzo di Medici of Florence during Renaissance around 14th century AD, Chanakya authored ‘Arthashastra’ for Chandragupta Maurya in the late BC/early AD - exact time period is unknown. Machiavelli propounded the importance of Secular nature, i.e, separation of Roman catholic church from politics while Chanakya advises King to follow dharma and religion both and have in fact put King below Dharma ‘righteaousness’ while Machiavelli puts King above everything. Both have been compared to one another - the unknown to the known.


From the Penguin Classics, this version of Kautilya's 'The Arthashastra' is edited, rearranged and introduced by L.N. Rangarajan; dedicating the book to R. Shamasastry who discovered the test and translated it first and R. P. Kangle's whose work was used as the authoritative work for this translation. Preface begins with how both Kautilya the preceptor and his masterwork the Arthashastra are much misunderstood.




The great aims of human endeavour have been classified as being four - Dharma (moral behavior), Artha ( wealth), Kama ( worldly pleasure) and Moksha ( salvation). Artha follows Dharma and Kautilya's Arthashastra can be looked at as a valuable document which throws light on the state and society in that time, whether it be 300 B.C or 150 AD or Kautilya can be regarded as a great preceptor of statecraft, whose teachings have a universal validity. It is a practical work, covering how to form alliances, how to attack a powerful king, how to deal with revolts in the rear, what tricks to play on gullible people - presumed to be implemented then.

The source of livelihood of men is wealth. Wealth of a nation is both the territory of the state and its inhabitants who may follow a variety of occupations. The state or government has a crucial role to play in maintaining the material well-being of the nation and its people. Therefore, an important part of Arthashastra is 'the science of economics/politics', including starting productive enterprises, taxation, revenue collection, budget and accounts. The aim of pursuing successful economic policies, particularly through productive enterprises, is also to increase the revenues of the state and appropriate the surplus for the state treasury. A king with a depleted treasury eats into the very vitality of the citizens and the country. If he impoverishes his own people or angers them will lose loyalty [7.5.27]. A balance has to be maintained between the welfare of the people and augmenting the resources of the state. This presupposes maintenance of law and order and adequate administrative machinery.

Part I

Introductory Section


"This Arthashastra is a compendium of almost all similar treaties composed by ancient teachers, on the acquisition and protection of territory. (1.1.1)"

"The people of a society, whatever their varna or stage of life, will follow their own dharma and pursue with devotion their occupations, if they are protected by the king and the just use of danda (coercion and punishment) (1.4.16)"

" The source of the livelihood of men is artha (wealth); that is to say, the territory (and the inhabitants following various professions) is the wealth [of a nation]. The science by which territory is acquired and maintained is Arthashastra - the science of wealth and welfare. [15.1.1.1]

Knowledge has four branches, philosophy, Vedas, economics and the science of government. Philosophy is the lamp that illuminates all sciences, it provides the techniques for all action; and it is the pillar which supports dharma.

The auxiliary sciences are phonetics, ritual, grammar, etymology, prosody and astronomy.

The three Vedas are most useful because they establish the respective duties of the four varnas and the four stages of life. The four stages of life are that of a householder, Brahmachari, Vanaprastha (forest recluse), and Parivrajaka (a wandering ascetic).

Duties common to all are Ahimsa, Satyam, cleanliness, freedom from malice, compassion and tolerance.

CONFLICTS: Four methods to deal conflict are: Sama, Dana, bheda and danda i.e. adopting a conciliatory attitude, placating with rewards and gifts, sowing dissension among enemies and using force.

Part II


The State and its Constituent


" Kautilya says: There cannot be a country without people and there is no kingdom without a country" [13.4.5]

" The value of a land is what man makes of it" [7.11.9.]

" In the interest of the prosperity of the country, a king should be diligent in foreseeing the possibility of calamities, try to avert them before they arise, overcome those which happen, remove all obstructions to economic activity and prevent loss of revenue to the state" [8.4.50]

This covers the qualities required by different people, how to deal with calamities and adversities. It is important to know of people's vices because they are the cause of personal adversities. Vices are due to ignorance and indiscipline; an unlearned man does not perceive the injurious consequences of his vices.

The main vices are Anger and Desire.

Three kind of vices are due to anger and four due to uncontrolled desire. Of the two, anger is worse because it knows no boundaries. It is wel known that angry kings have often been killed by popular fury, whereas greedy and lustful kings have perished by disease, poverty or enemy actions.

The three kind of vices arising from anger are inflicting verbal injury, causing injury to another's property and inflicting physical injury. Injuring another's property includes: not giving what is due, taking away unjustly, destroying it and neglecting entrusted property. Anger makes one the object of hatred, creates enemies and brings suffering on oneself.

The four vices springing from excessive desire are addiction to hunting, gambling, women and drink. Excessive greed and lust bring about humiliation, loss of wealth and association with undesirable persons.

Excessive desire leads to the cultivation of evil things while anger causes the abandonment of good things. Since both results in multitude of evils, both are classified as calamities. One need to exercise self-control.

Part III

The King


Often used to signify the state. The three science (philosophy, the three Vedas and economics) are dependent for their development on the science of government.

The sole aim of all branches of knowledge is to inculcate restraint over the senses. Self-control, which is the basis of knowledge and discipline, is acquired by giving up lust, anger, greed, conceit, arrogance and foolhardiness. Living in accordance with the shastras means avoiding over-indulgence in all pleasures of hearing, touch, sight, taste and smell.
It describe the duties of The King, Kings security, ever present dangers like - revolts/rebellions/conspiracies and treason, succession, regency,

Per Kautilya people will naturally obey a high-born king though he is weak, because a man of nobility has a natural capacity to rule. Furthermore, people frustrate the intrigues of the low-born, however strong he may be, because, as the saying goes: 'Where there is love, one sees all the virtues in the beloved'.

Part IV

The Well Organized State


" A king can reign only with the help of others; one wheel alone does not move (a chariot). Therefore, a king should appoint advisers (as councillors and ministers) and listen to their advice."

"The root of wealth is economic activity and lack of it brings material distress. In the absence of fruitful economic activity, both current prosperity and future growth are in danger of destruction."

This deals with how land and roads should be, how a king should choose his Councillors and ministers. Also the chapter on aspects of the economy gives details of agriculture, different industries and types of economic activities. It also gives guidelines on customs regulations comsumer protection.

Part V

Treasury, Sources of Revenue, Budget, Accounts and Audit



If receipts and expenditure are properly looked after the king will not find himself in financial difficulties. Sources of revenue are:
1) Income from crown property (agricultural land), mining and metallurgy, animal husbandry, irrigation works,
2) Income from state controlled activities like manufacturing industries like textiles, food items, liquor, leisure activity
3) Taxes in cash and in kind, including customs, cess, royalty and surcharges
4) Trade
5) Fees and service charges
6) Miscellaneous covering interests, aids, presents, foreign affairs, court cases, savings, fines, special levies, donations,

Accounts are to be properly maintained and audited.

Part VI

Civil Service Regulations



Part VII

The Department's of the Government



Part VIII

Law and Justice


The idea of justice and punishment is same - punishment in proportion of crime. Dandaniti of Chanakya.


"Judge shall discharge their duties objectively and impartially so that they may earn the trust and affection of the people" (3.20.24)

Judge was called 'dharmastha' - upholder of dharma'. Ultimate source of all law was Dharma.

The subject covers both civil law called ' Concerning upholder of dharma' in book 3 and criminal law including Penal code in book 4 called 'The removal of Thorns' i.e elemination of antisocial elements.

Prevention of crime is an aspect of maintenance of law and order.


Part IX


Covert Operations


"Miraculous results can be achieved by practising the methods of subversion"

The creation of a secret service, with spies, secret agents and specialists such as assassins, was a task of high priority for the king, so also the testing of the integrity of appointed ministers. This applies to both men and women. The chancellors and the security too had network of spies. The could be as monks, householders, merchants or ascetics both brahminical and non brahminical.

This includes Magic, illusion and occult as well.

Part X

Foreign Policy


"The welfare of a state depends on an active foreign policy" [6.2.1]

The state is not a monolithic entity but with 6 internal constituents - the king, the ministers, the fortified city, the countryside, the treasury and the army.

The six methods of foreign policy are - Making peace, waging war, staying quiet, preparing for war, seeking support and adopting a dual policy - i.e. making peace with one and war with other.

All these six methods are interdependent.


Part XI

Defence and War


"To be in accordance with dharma, the place and time of battle must be specified beforehand" [10.3.26]

Even after acquiring any new territory, dharma must be followed and in case not; it has to be implemented.

For a mighty king the cycle of acquisition by conquest is a recurring process; the eventual objective being chakravarthikshetram - the area of operation of the king-Emperor - which as per 9.1.18 is the area extending from the Himalayas in the north to the sea (in the south) and a thousand yojanas wide from east to west is the area of operation of the king-Emperor this area is the whole of Bharatavarsha i.e. The Indian, Sub-continent. The last verse in this translation, reiterates that the King-Emperor shall rule in accordance with dharma.

Verse 1.13.5-10 ' When there was no order in society and only the law of jungle prevailed, the made Manu, the son of Vivasvat, their king.

The book from translation by R.P. Kangle's who based his writings from palm leaf manuscript about 300 years old, is not the original text.


A Science of Living.



Monday, December 23, 2019

3S's - Shashi Tharoor, Sharad Pawar and Subramanian Swamy (ST,SP & SS)



gerontocracy
/ˌdʒɛrənˈtɒkrəsi/

noun
a state, society, or group governed by old people.
government based on rule by old people.

Having written about 3S's Female Politicians - thought why delay to write on the men - why not when they are alive - and in this year itself? Came across an article by Shashi Tharoor - 'In praise of Gerontocracy' which brought one more similarity among them.

As quoted by ST - 'The New England Journal of Medicine' - Most productive age in human life is 60-70, next 70-80 and then 50-60. That is the age when they have acquired skills, made and learned from mistakes, and can focus on sharpening and deploying their skills. So these men are in their best years of their life, politically very active and have been creating headlines.

The youngest of the three, his charm works wonders, irrespective of your gender, is one of the best debaters India has ever produced. His excellent wit, apt humor, throat slitting points, his ever lasting charismatic style made him most famous among the elite circle, he is a non-official English teacher to many, who teach through tweeter, has written 20 books' 10 of them after his 50's; and has tarnished his image for being the suspicious wife killer, - who is liked for his writings and speeches, especially in international forums. He is an example of how just soft skills are not enough to prosper in life but can give you a certain edge. When politics by itself has become a comedy show, this year he participated in One mike stand - entertaining millions around the globe. Also he won the prestigious Sahitya Akademi Award for his book - 'An Era of Darkness' . A Malayalee from Palakad, three times MP from Trivandurm, born in UK, studied in Mumbai, Calcutta and Delhi, was the youngest PHd holder from US, he completed his doctorate in political science from Tuft University, worked with UN for almost 30 years. Shashi joined politics after his bid to become Secretary General of United Nations failed . He joined Indian National Congress and briefly served as Union Minister of state for external affairs (2009–2010) .Shashi Tharoor was all set to be next Minister of External affairs till a controversial tweet turned tables against him. IPL controvesy also greatly harm his public image.According to him if India must change, we have to re-introduce Indians to their Indianness. He believes in civilised discourse, and has been criticised for praising the opposition a couple of times. The Tharoorian Ideology rests on the three principles of Liberalism, Pluralism and Soft Power. Some belive that Tharoor joining the Congress was the downside of his career, he has been throughout seen as a level headed intellectual.


SS -

A Statistician, Number cruncher, holds a doctorate in economics from Harvard University at the age of 24, served as a professor in Harvard University and IIT, supposed to be a scholar in Chinese. He won Mumbai MP Seat in 1971. During emergency, he did a surprise entry into Parliament to keep up his MP seat & sneaked out of Delhi without getting arrested. speaks about his agility, network & guts.He was part of Sarvodaya Movement and had opposed national emergency .He was a member of Union cabinet led by Chandra Shekhar. He holds a long parliamentary career -five time Rajya Sabha member; one time Lok sabha member from Madurai (Tamil Nadu). Dr Subramanian- a Rajya Sabha member- is not part of Union Government; but is known as an influencer. His controversial views and acerbic language are admired by many in government and political circles. Regardless of his right winger image ; Dr Swamy is tolerant of all religions. His wife is a Parsee; one son in law is a muslim ;and a sister in law is a christian and another is a Sikh . Swamy is the man of action, over period of time he developed his own wit in interacting with different sections of media and Political spheres. True Indian heart and mind in action. To pull down the Bajpyee government - he brought together Sonia, Jayalalitha and Mayavathi and called them Sarashwathi, Lakshmi and Durga. His legal acumen as reflected in cases like 2G scam, coalgate, National Herald scam, disproportionate asset case...is unparalleled in contemporary Indian political and legal fraternity. He was instrumental in the Ramjanmabhoomi- Bhabri Masjid decision, and is believed to be one, who introduced the concept on faith into the decision/judgement, which was always disputed on the grounds of the possession of land untill then. His intellect in terms of economic acumen to impeccable political leadership to anti corruption crusader is well known in respective fields. He also has deep understanding in foreign policy matters. His contribution as an economist in 1991 economic reforms has been well acknowledged by none other than Dr. Manmohan Singh. His long political career has been impeccable and full of integrity. Apart from these, his insights into sociocultural evolutionary history of Indian society is remarkable. SS talks of facts and they have also supporting evidence. His first Law teacher was his wife Roxna Swamy who wrote his biography - 'Evolving with Subramanian Swamy a roller coaster ride'. A smart, intelligent man normally known to substantiate claims with proof, but deep within can cling to a charge even where it is unsubstantiated. Has a loose tongue, and is sadly a motor mouth. As he grows old, his criticism of his own party men including others not knowing Economics, and how things would be different, if he was made a Finance Minister is always mentioned by him in his interviews.

SP -

A professional politician by practice, has mastered the game over the years. He was the youngest CM in India at the age of 37 without any formal Godfather(at the background all know that Mr Yashwantrao Chavan was behind him). He was ICC Chairman, writer, Businessman who value Agriculture. He definitely would have aspired to be the PM, but could not; he was influential in having women in defense, when the cause of his oral cancel was detected to be his habit of chewing tobacca, he not only stopped that but banned it from the whole of India. For him there are no friends and enemies - very down to earth, but would stand up for what he want's - The first lot of three people who did not support Sonia Gandhi leading INC, and therefore formed NCP. The blasts, which left 357 people dead and 717 others injured, on a Black Friday (12th March 1993) in Bombay just two weeks after SP took charge as the CM and hardly a year after demolition of Babri Masjid. He foresaw the riots. He immediately held a live TV broadcast (doordarshan) and announced that 12 blasts had happened, the last one being at Masjid Bandar- a predominantly Muslim locality. He also stated that LTTE hand was suspected.The news did its job perfectly. The blasts could no longer be stereotyped as a Muslim action targeted against Hindus. - Justice Shrikrishna Commission, which later investigated the bombings, lauded Sharad Pawar for this lie. They even remarked- ‘That’s one bomb that saved so many lives.’Like a suspense thriller novel or a movie, everybody double-crossed everybody else in the recent Maharashtra elections. When the morning news papers read that the Shiv Sena, NCP, Congress Trio was to form the government - BJP had already took the oath and formed the government - SP was not to give up. Supreme Court opened on Sunday - asked them to prove majority. MLA's were taken to hotel in Delhi - They were all brought back and MLA's of all the three party was together untill majority was proved and the collision formed the government, but for him and his NCP.

Thanks to people like the 3's - Politics today is worthy of cinema, tutorial for English language and there are people out of the dynastic INC challenging the other wise majority government who has become autocratic, divisive and sham.

Wednesday, December 18, 2019

Dharma Vs. Karma


The word dharma is formed from the sanskrit root 'dhr', to hold, dharma is therefore that which holds a person or object and maintains it in existence, it is the law that governs its being. To live according to dharma is to be in consonance with the truth of things. A moral life, for a Hindu, is a life lived in accordance with his dharma, which in turn must be in conformity with the absolute truth that encompasses the universe.

"The fundamental difference between religion (dharma) and karma is that whilst dharma shows a way for people to live and conduct their lives with purpose, karma refers to the consequences of your actions resulting from the way people live that life."

"The term Dharma is defined in Mīmāṁsa as:—

Dharma is that which leads to the highest common good (śreyas) [and, is distinguished by Vedic injunctions - vidhi].

Dharma is “right living” defined by the practice of universal ethics and personal morals.

The Mahabharata defines Dharma:–

dhāraṇād dharma ityāhuḥ dharmo dhārayate prajāḥ |

ya syād dhāraṇa samyuktaḥ sa dharma iti niścayaḥ ||

The word Dharma is derived from dhāraṇa or sustenance; dharma sustains society. That which has the capacity to sustain is indeed dharma. (M.B. Karna Parva 69:58)

“Dharma” cannot be known through empirical means such as cognition. It can be known only either through intuition or through an impersonal source of knowledge.

The problem with relying on reason or intuition is that individuals will come to differing conclusions about what the ultimate nature of the “Common Good” is.

There are endless controversies on most if not all ethical issues by “experts” who take one side or the other.

The best and most universal source of Dharma therefore, would be an “impersonal” source such as the Vedas.

What is Dharma?

Dharma refers to Harmony, The Way, Righteousness, Compassion, Natural Law, Truth, Teachings, Tradition, Philosophy, Order, Universal, Flow, Religion, Wisdom, Divine Conformity, Cosmic Norm, Blueprint, Inherent Nature, Law of Being, and Duty.

The science of conduct, the systematized principles according to which one should act.

Ethical science is a relative science — relative to the individual and one's surroundings and circumstances.

The purpose of morality is to bring about happiness for the maximum number of people by creating harmony.

Harmony between individuals of a family, between families of a community, between communities that live together in a nation. Harmony between nations that make up humanity. Harmony between humankind and the environment and other creatures that share our earth. And harmony between earthlings and the inhabitants of other worlds.

Where there is harmony there is happiness, disharmony cause unhappiness.

The ultimate object of morality is to bring about universal happiness.

The underlying principle of Dharma is the recognition of the unity of the Self and the diversity of the not-self.

Examples of Dharma:-

Ijyayācarā damo’himsā dānam svādhyāya karma ca | Ayaṃ ca paramo dharmo yad yogena ātma darśanam || (Manu 2:7)

Altruism (ijyacara), control of mind, non-violence, charity, self-study, work, realisation of the Atman by means of Yoga — all these are Dharmas.

adrohaḥ sarvabhūteṣu karmaṇā manasā girā | anugrahaśca dānaṃ ca stāṃ dharma sanātanaḥ ||

The Eternal Duty (Sanātana Dharma) towards all creatures is the absence of malevolence towards them in thought, deed or word, and to practice compassion and generosity towards them. (MB Vana Parva 297;35)

satyam damas tapaḥ śaucaṁ santoṣaśca kṣamārjavam | jñānaṁ śamo dānaṁ eṣā dharmaḥ sanātana ||

Sanatana Dharma consists of truth, discipline, austerity, purity, contentment, forgiveness and honesty, knowledge, peacefulness and generosity. (Garuda Purana 1:213:24)"

"Duty is what should motivate everyone. Duty or Ethics is known as Dharma and is the way and the end in itself.

Is a person who does good and lives an ethical life for the sake of self-glorification and some future heavenly reward really virtuous? Or should virtue be an end in itself.

If you do good only through fear of hell then you are a fake and a fraud and merely suppressing and masking your inherent malevolent nature.

The Gita tells us never to be concerned for the fruit of action, but you should find your joy and purpose in the doing itself.

All philosophers have addressed this issue."

"Let us now understand the meaning of Gita in this new perspective. When our mind is focused on the results (of future), we can’t enjoy what we are doing (at present). You would have perhaps acquired more knowledge from the book, had you read it with joy instead of getting something out of it. In the same way, when you play tennis with your friend without bothering about winning or losing, you enjoy the game the most. If you are playing better tennis than your friend, you are anyway going to win with or without aiming for it. Even when you lose the game, you have still enjoyed the play.

When you stop thinking about the fruits of your action, and learn to just enjoy the action itself; you get a new meaning of your life. There is a paradigm shift in your life. Instead of looking others as your rival, you learn to see them as friends. You develop a sportsman spirit and you accept your victory or defeat in the same spirit. It does not matter to you if a hundred million people have already read ‘Angles and Demons’ as their enjoyment does not reduce your enjoyment? Your joy is coterminous with your action and you develop no attachment with your action.

It is thus evident that actions without aspiration of fruits are better than action done for achieving a goal. The more you perform such action, the better your life would be"

You participate in competition ,but the first serve the needy or you offer to God
Negates the karma

That is why we first offer to God as prasadam.

Thus:

Dharma and karma are Sanskrit concepts that have been codified through the practice of indigenous Indian religions. ... Dharma refers to one's lifelong duty whereas karma refers to someone's day to day actions and the negative or positive obligations these actions bring about

Karma is a concept of Hinduism which explains causality through a system where beneficial effects are derived from past beneficial actions and harmful effects from past harmful actions, creating a system of actions and reactions throughout a soul's (Atman's) reincarnated lives forming a cycle of rebirth.

Wednesday, December 11, 2019

The Legend of Khasak - O.V. Vijayan



The Legend of Khasak is a ballad of re-enactment. Thasarak as the Malayalam place name go, provides the interface, rest is no real life Eden. A short book with great deal of details, first published in Malayalam in 1969, as Khasakkinte Itihasam by O.V. Vijayan, with the English translation as well by him in 1994. Though late glad I got hold of it. Wondering if it has anything similar to 100 days of solitude?



The District Board has established a single teacher school in remote Khasak, in a an effort to give the local children access to basic education, and Ravi is to be the first teacher there. Ravi is the outsider in this place, but he easily fits in the scheme of things here. The smaller stories and individual fates are appealing and well blend into the whole. It also includes, Beliefs and superstitions that make sense in this small world, co-existence of religion, modern world intrigues with tradition, not involved around just a single character, but r

Vijayan carefully avoids presenting the book too closely as an educational journey but is very evocative, covering a great deal from various aspects of life in few pages, forward clearly say the English version cannot do full justice to the malayalam one, as there are limitations, but an interesting read indeed, especially considering the time it was written. Hence the normal saying - In Malayalam literature they say - there was a period before Khasak and after Khasak.

Angel by the River by Gus Speth : Environmental Issues + Job and Education today


What Gus Speth has pointed out is absolutely true - The root cause of all problems, including environmental, (and the solution lies in) cultivating compassion, empathy, cultural transformation, civic sense, etc. A change of mindset of people is the need of the hour.

James Gustave Speth an American environmental lawyer and advocate in Living on Earth – Gus Speth calls for a New Environmentalism. First aired on February 13, 2015. In conversation with host Steve Curwood, NRDC co-founder Gus Speth reflects on the environmental movement both as a previous ‘insider’ and now as a reformer. In his new memoir “Angels by the River” Gus Speth calls for deeper challenges to the economic status quo, and explores his life and career at the nexus of race, environment and politics.

“I used to think that top environmental problems were biodiversity loss, ecosystem collapse and climate change. I thought that thirty years of good science could address these problems. I was wrong. The top environmental problems are selfishness, greed and apathy, and to deal with these we need a cultural and spiritual transformation. And we scientists don’t know how to do that.”

Environmental system includes - strengthen economic, political and social security - which can be strengthened with strong laws, powerful system and ethics. This can happen with radical leadership. So it is no more confined to Air, Water, or Sound pollution. Need to save democracy, which have a huge say in the investments. Give priority to people and planet and not profit.


Some more interesting quotes from Gus Speth are:


This describes the plight of our society aptly, why Schools and colleges are no more important in India.... People need to follow and be Sadhus and Swami's or politics...well the crowd follow the leader right....

People with high mark take science, and go for B.Tech
Next Commerce, do MBA
Next take Arts do IAS
Just basic school be politicians and
those with no education becomes Sadhu and

Once in job the reporting is in reverse order: - Engineering graduates, report to MBA's, they work under IAS - all of whom are governed by the politicians; and everyone in turn go to the Sadhu's for blessings.


Once in job:

People leave in 6 months - Employers want at least 3 years retainer ship.

They must understand that the world of Business has seen 3 revolution:

Industrial revolution - Even if boss abused people stuck, boss was always right, Survival had to be taken care of - Our parents age
Information revolution - went to work for Standard of living, had options for better jobs - This included people of - Our age
Digital/Social revolution - Survival and Standard of life is taken care of - Today people look for quality of life, work place, job, environment, role, opportunity, learning and reward. - Since 2008

Tuesday, December 03, 2019

Shashi Tharoor tells #AsiaLitFest about the books that shaped his life



https://www.asialitfest.co.uk/post/shashi-tharoor-tells-asialitfest-about-the-books-that-shaped-his-life

Shashi Tharoor: Books That Shaped My Life- Tharoor was in conversation with journalist and author Shrabani Basu

The prominent Indian politician and bestselling author was discussing the books that have most influenced him in his life.

The Great Indian Novel first paragraph was read - and I did have that book with me - another connection - Inspired from the Grand Epic which has been around for more than 800 years – everything was into it – people, told and retold and included in it everything worth adding. At the same time it was a secular epic. Characters are human with lust, greed, ambition, envy and so on.

Took epic and retold as satiric novel – Ved Vyas dictates the novel to Ganesh – satirical tale with triumphs and failures.

Unofficial English teacher to many across the world, through his twitter - two words were discussed viz:

1) Floccinaucinihilipilification (noun) - First used to introduce the release of his new book - 'The Paradoxical PrimeMinister'

Pronounciation: floccī-naucī-nihilī-pilī-fication

Meaning: The action or habit of estimating something as worthless.

2) Hippopotomonstrosesquipedaliophobia (noun) - Used to justify the use of the above word.

Pronounciation: hip‧po‧po‧to‧mon‧stro‧ses‧qui‧pe‧dal‧i‧o‧pho‧bi‧a

Meaning: The fear of long words.


1) Heavy weather - 95 books by P.G. Wodehouse read all of them by 15- easier to choose an author than a book – Wodehouse – Left England as a young men – and therefore he reinvented England - subversion of language – classical illusion – fed into our subversive spirit – surprised lot of people that he had more followers than in India than UK. Represent so much of the joy language gave. Died in 1975 - Heavy weather has Absurd plot – prize pig known as empress which was logo of woodhouse society. Plotting incredible. As a kid ST read widely and indiscriminately, inconveniently fast. Reading was his education, entertainment and escape from suffering.

2) 100 days of solitude – Garcia – was famous in Latin America. It expands the realm of possible on what you can do with fiction. Experience that is lived by the character through a shuttle stretching of human imagination.

3) O.V. Vijayan – The Legends of Kasak. – Huge controversy of English version. Made living as political cartoonist as there was no money for Indian fiction writer. Book is subtly different – Young men going to obscure village where he is asked by govt. to set up one man school – It captures Kerala so well – where ideal India should be.

4) The discovery of India – Magisterial work, Philosophy, history, politics, history, culture, society, - remarkable work by a remarkable mind - with no reference but discussion with fellow jailers - Great pity people have forgotten Nehru – effective democratic politician, brilliant writer, influential person of 20th century – he wrote biography of Nehru – A wonder of such sharp insight – choices in context – presumptuous enough – train his mind to be like Nehru’s – Understand why people did what they do in the context of pressure and situation then. Not easy time but trying to be opposition – agree on the ground rule on how you disagree.

5) Arthashastra – 4th century B.C. – 2000 years old on state craft – humane work – good governance, justice, justification for governments rule to be welfare of people, - Neighbours enemy is friend – talk about human integrity – very sophisticated text – on spying, Artha is material success. The pursuit of four things of life – Dharma, Artha (Wealth), Kama (love, desire, sex); Moksha (salvation); - Penguine one is good. Notion of good governance are profound ideas.

If he could carry only One book and was left in a desert – Mahabharata - Unabridged thing is enormous – so many digression - 5 times the length of bible -

Why choose congress? Right path to put forward the liberal idea – going to congress means accepting the reality as it is. Party finds a tug of unity behind the family. Last 2 congress prime minister who ruled for 15 years were not congress. Leadership don’t monopolies the top position. Competence, skill, experience, are great strength. One party dominant thinking - Foreign policy – Tradition – part of culture to showcase to the world we are of one view opposition party shared this space but for first time now - Minister of state for home in previous govt. is now acting.

Irish Education effect? Convey ethical system, Jesuit good teacher. Epistemological lectures of the presence of God.

Too backlashes over globalization – economic – blue collar job’s migration; and cultural backlashes – intensified and raised in western country visible/audible minority. Placed a different premium on native-ism. David Goodheart – Brithish philosopher - Somewhere and Anywhere – Theresa Mais – if you think you are citizen of the world, you don’t know what citizenship is - Davos man - “Davos men” or “gold-collar workers.”

One favorite Character - Difficult to be both – narrator and character – Ved Vyas.

Asia House – Pluralism and diversity that makes literature interesting.

Inspiration – increasingly at night, was an early bird and now a night owl.

Depending on the mood – pluralism should be the favorite word. Make the world interesting place.

Literature and Politics both have human conditions. Should deal with universal principals Solutions – compatible fields to be in.

His reply to a student who asked him to give him a new word in view of his reputation as a fount of exotic vocabulary was - 'Read'.



Monday, December 02, 2019

Being respectful - Civility is the need of hour



What you want to be? Your actions determine it.

Be civil. Incivility is a bug and it is contagious. You can catch this anywhere - at home, around us. It takes our energy.

Looking to get ahead in your career? Start by being respectful to your coworkers, says leadership researcher Christine Porath. In this science-backed talk, she shares surprising insights about the costs of rudeness and shows how little acts of respect can boost your professional success -- and your company's bottom line.

https://www.ted.com/talks/christine_porath_why_being_respectful_to_your_coworkers_is_good_for_business?utm_source=linkedin.com&utm_medium=social&utm_campaign=tedspread

Respect and result, is the key. Will help reduce stress. Help achieve goal.

Smile, care personally - even when you challenge.

Be Competent, Friendly and Smart.

What do people want most from their leader - being treated with respect. More important than appreciation and feedback.

Thank people, share credit, acknowledge others, listen attentively, humbly asking question, and smiling has an impact.

When you are withing 10 feet away from people smile and make eye contact; when you are withing 5 feet away, say hello.

Be Tough minded, but tender hearted. Make people feel valued. Be agile and mindful.