Sunday, November 15, 2026

Format

 Other stories that would make excellent chapters or case studies

I would select stories from different countries and periods. Each illustrates a different weakness in financial reporting. The reader would gradually understand why accounting standards, disclosures, independent audits and corporate governance matter.



1. Satyam Computer Services – The cash that did not exist

Essential Indian case study

In January 2009, chairman B. Ramalinga Raju admitted that Satyam's accounts contained inflated cash and bank balances, fictitious accrued interest, understated liabilities and overstated debtors.


Accounting lesson: Bank confirmations, existence of assets, audit evidence, revenue and profit reliability, internal controls.


A powerful Indian example of how a balance sheet can look healthy while the underlying financial position is very different. 

BSE India+1




2. Enron – The company that hid its debts


The American energy giant used complex special-purpose entities and accounting arrangements to keep certain debts and losses away from its reported balance sheet.


Accounting lesson: Consolidation, control, related-party disclosures, substance over form and off-balance-sheet arrangements.


This is an excellent story for explaining why the financial statements of a group must reflect the economic reality of entities it controls. 

SEC+1




3. Wirecard – The missing €1.9 billion


The German payments company reported substantial cash balances that could not be verified. In 2020, the company disclosed that €1.9 billion supposedly held in trustee accounts probably did not exist.


Accounting lesson: Cash and bank balance verification, audit independence, confirmation procedures, auditor responsibility and regulatory supervision.


This is particularly useful because it shows that even sophisticated financial reporting systems and large audit firms cannot eliminate the need for professional scepticism. 

ESMA+1




4. Carillion – Profits on paper, collapse in reality


The British construction and services company collapsed in January 2018. Its reported financial strength had concealed serious problems involving contracts, debt, cash flows and pension obligations.


Accounting lesson: Revenue recognition, contract accounting, provisions, liabilities, going concern and cash-flow reporting.


The British parliamentary inquiry is particularly useful for understanding the gap between reported profits and the financial health of a business. 

House of Commons+2




5. Toshiba – The pressure to show profits


In 2015, Toshiba acknowledged inappropriate accounting practices involving the recognition of profits, including long-term infrastructure projects. An independent investigation examined how management pressure contributed to the problem.


Accounting lesson: Percentage-of-completion accounting, revenue recognition, estimates, management override and corporate governance.


This case is useful for showing how pressure to meet profit targets can influence accounting judgements. 

global.toshiba



4. Other stories worth considering

There are several more cases that could enrich the book:

Company / case What makes it interesting Accounting connection

Parmalat (Italy) A supposedly large bank deposit turned out to be fictitious. Cash verification, audit evidence, consolidation

Luckin Coffee (China) Fabricated sales and revenue figures. Revenue recognition, internal controls

Nirav Modi / PNB (India) Fraudulent bank guarantees and weaknesses in banking controls. Contingent liabilities, disclosures, internal controls

DHFL (India) Complex lending, related-party transactions and questions about financial reporting. Financial assets, impairment, related parties

IL&FS (India) A major infrastructure group defaulted despite its earlier reputation and ratings. Consolidation, liquidity, debt, going concern


I would use Parmalat, Luckin Coffee and PNB as supporting examples rather than giving every case a full chapter. They broaden the reader's understanding of the different ways financial information can become unreliable.

5. How to organise these stories in your book

Rather than placing all the fraud cases together as a catalogue, I would organise them around the accounting questions they raise.

Part I – The numbers that misled investors

- Satyam – Where did the cash go?

- Rajesh Exports – Why were the receivables not being collected?

- Luckin Coffee – Were the sales real?


Part II – What the Balance Sheet did not reveal

- Enron – Where were the debts?

- Parmalat – Did the cash exist?

- DHFL – What was happening behind the lending figures?


Part III – When profits concealed the problem

- Carillion – How healthy was the business really?

- Toshiba – Were the profits recognised too early?

- Wirecard – Who verified the cash?


Part IV – The lessons for investors and the profession

- The importance of financial statement disclosures.

- The responsibility of auditors and directors.

- The role of regulators and standard setters.

- Why investors must read beyond the Profit and Loss Account.


6. A common storytelling format for every case

I suggest following the same five-part structure for each story:

1. The promise: What did the company look like to investors? What made it attractive?

2. The numbers: What did its financial statements report?

3. The warning sign: What first raised questions? Who noticed it?

4. The discovery: What did investigations reveal, and what remains disputed?

5. The accounting lesson: Which accounting principle, disclosure requirement, audit procedure or governance mechanism does the case help us understand?

This will make the book accessible to readers who have never studied accounting.


For example, after telling the Satyam story, you could explain what a bank confirmation is and why an auditor cannot simply rely on a bank balance appearing in the company's ledger.


After Enron, you could explain why a subsidiary or special-purpose entity may need to be consolidated even when its legal structure appears separate.


After Carillion, you could explain why profit is not the same as cash and why the going-concern assumption matters.


One important thought for the book: Do not make it a book about corporate scandals alone. Make it a book about why trustworthy financial reporting matters. For every story of failure, explain the accounting principle that exists to protect the reader of the financial statements.


I would even consider opening this section with a simple question:


If a company reports a profit of ₹1,000 crore, how do we know that it has actually earned it? If it reports cash of ₹5,000 crore, how do we know that the money is really in the bank? And if it reports phenomenal growth, how do we know that the business behind those numbers exists?


Those three questions could take your reader through the entire world of accounting standards and financial reporting.

No comments: