Bookkeeping → public companies → investors → financial crises → regulation → national standards → global standards → Indian convergence with IFRS
Here is the story in simple terms.
1. Before regulation: accounting was largely a matter of practice
For centuries, businesses maintained accounts according to established commercial practices, professional judgement and local customs. There were accounting principles, but there was no single global authority telling every business exactly how a transaction had to be reported.
This became increasingly problematic as businesses grew into corporations. Ownership became separated from management, shares began to be widely held by the public, and investors started putting money into businesses they did not personally know.
The financial statements of a company were therefore becoming much more than an internal record. They were becoming information on which strangers made financial decisions.
That created the need for greater consistency and credibility.
2. The 1929 stock-market crash changed the story
The Wall Street crash of October 1929 was a major turning point in the United States.
During the 1920s, stock-market participation had expanded dramatically. Many people invested in shares, often using borrowed money. There was also considerable enthusiasm and speculation, while the quality and reliability of information available to investors were not what we would expect today.
When the market collapsed, enormous amounts of wealth disappeared. Investor confidence collapsed along with it. The SEC itself describes the period as one in which substantial investments became worthless and public confidence in the securities markets was severely damaged. SEC
The lesson was not simply that markets could fall.
It was that investors needed reliable information before they put their money at risk.
And that brought accounting directly into the world of regulation.
3. The birth of the SEC
In response to the crisis, the US Congress passed the Securities Act of 1933 and the Securities Exchange Act of 1934.
The latter established the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) in 1934.
The SEC's purpose was much broader than accounting. It became the principal regulator of US securities markets, with a central responsibility for investor protection and full and fair disclosure. Congress also gave the SEC authority over accounting and financial reporting for companies subject to US securities laws. SEC
This was a profound change.
Accounting was no longer simply something that accountants and businessmen could work out among themselves.
Financial reporting had become a matter of public interest.
The government was essentially saying:
If the public is investing its money in companies, the public deserves reliable information about those companies.
4. But the SEC did something interesting
The SEC had the legal authority to prescribe accounting requirements, but it did not decide to write every accounting rule itself.
Instead, it largely relied on the expertise of the accounting profession and private-sector standard setters. The SEC retained oversight and the legal authority to intervene when necessary. SEC
This eventually contributed to the development of what Americans call US GAAP.
GAAP means:
Generally Accepted Accounting Principles.
It is not one single accounting standard. It is the broad body of authoritative accounting principles and requirements used in US financial reporting.
Over the decades, US GAAP evolved through several standard-setting bodies.
A simplified history is:
Committee on Accounting Procedure (CAP)
→ Accounting Principles Board (APB)
→ Financial Accounting Standards Board (FASB)
The FASB was established in 1973 and became the principal private-sector standard setter for US financial accounting. The SEC recognises FASB's standards as generally accepted for purposes of federal securities law. SEC
So, in very simple terms:
SEC = regulator
FASB = accounting standard setter
US GAAP = body of accounting requirements used in the US
That distinction is important.
5. Meanwhile, the world was becoming smaller
While the US was developing its own system, another transformation was taking place.
International business was growing rapidly after the Second World War. Companies were operating across borders. Investors were buying securities in foreign countries. Multinational groups were becoming increasingly important.
And a new problem appeared.
Imagine an American investor looking at a company in Germany, a company in Britain and a company in Japan.
All three might be perfectly legitimate businesses. But their financial statements could be prepared according to very different national accounting traditions.
The investor was effectively trying to compare apples with oranges.
The world therefore began asking:
Could there be a common international accounting language?
6. IASC — the first major international attempt
In 1973, accounting bodies from nine countries came together in London and established the International Accounting Standards Committee (IASC).
The founding countries included Australia, Canada, France, Germany, Japan, Mexico, the Netherlands, the United Kingdom and Ireland, and the United States. IFRS Foundation
The idea was ambitious but simple:
similar transactions should, as far as possible, be accounted for in similar ways regardless of where they occurred.
The IASC began issuing International Accounting Standards, commonly known as IAS.
This is where many standards that you know from your IFRS studies originated.
For example:
- IAS 1 — Presentation of Financial Statements
- IAS 2 — Inventories
- IAS 7 — Statement of Cash Flows
- IAS 8 — Accounting Policies, Changes in Accounting Estimates and Errors
- IAS 12 — Income Taxes
- IAS 16 — Property, Plant and Equipment
- IAS 21 — Foreign Exchange
- IAS 23 — Borrowing Costs
- IAS 34 — Interim Financial Reporting
- IAS 36 — Impairment of Assets
- IAS 37 — Provisions
- IAS 38 — Intangible Assets
The IASC existed from 1973 to 2001. Its work laid the foundation for today's international system. IFRS Foundation
7. IASC becomes IASB
In 2001, the international standard-setting structure was reorganised.
The International Accounting Standards Board (IASB) was established, replacing the IASC's standard-setting board.
This is the point at which the terminology becomes easier to understand:
IASC → IAS
IASB → IFRS
But there is an important nuance.
The IASB did not throw away the old IAS standards.
Many IAS standards issued by the IASC continue to exist. The IASB subsequently began issuing new standards under the name IFRS — International Financial Reporting Standards. The IFRS Foundation confirms that when we use the term IFRS Standards today, it includes both the newer IFRS Standards and the IAS Standards inherited from the IASC. IFRS Foundation
So IAS 12 and IFRS 15 can quite happily sit beside each other.
IAS 12 belongs to the older generation of standards.
IFRS 15 belongs to the newer generation.
8. IFRS — the attempt to create a global accounting language
The larger ambition behind IFRS is not merely to produce a collection of accounting rules.
It is to create financial reporting that is comparable, transparent, understandable and useful for investors, lenders and other users.
Think about an investor who wants to compare two multinational companies.
If one company recognises revenue differently from another, or measures its assets differently, the investor may reach the wrong conclusion even if both companies have prepared their accounts honestly.
International standards try to reduce those differences.
The goal is therefore not:
“Make every company identical.”
It is:
“Make financial statements sufficiently consistent that meaningful comparisons can be made.”
9. Where does India enter this story?
India's journey has its own history.
The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India (ICAI) was established in 1949, and as the accounting profession developed, the need for formal accounting standards became increasingly important.
In 1977, ICAI constituted the Accounting Standards Board (ASB).
Its objective was to develop sound, reliable and high-quality accounting and financial reporting and to harmonise the diverse accounting policies and practices being followed in India. asb.icai.org
This is an important date for anyone studying Indian accounting:
1977 — ICAI establishes the Accounting Standards Board.
The ASB began developing India's Accounting Standards, which we know as AS.
These standards covered areas such as accounting policies, inventories, cash flows, depreciation, revenue recognition, foreign exchange and many others.
India was developing its own accounting framework while also increasingly looking towards international developments.
10. AS → Ind AS
As India's economy became more integrated with the global economy, the need for internationally comparable financial statements became stronger.
India therefore moved towards convergence with IFRS.
Notice the word:
Convergence
India did not simply say:
"We will adopt IFRS exactly as written."
Instead, India developed Ind AS — Indian Accounting Standards, which are substantially based on IFRS but contain certain differences, known as carve-outs and carve-ins, to reflect India's legal, economic and regulatory environment. ICAI
ICAI decided in 2006 to move towards convergence with IFRS. This was subsequently supported by the Government of India, and the roadmap was developed further over the following years. ICAI Knowledge Base
There was an initial attempt to notify Ind AS in 2011, but implementation was postponed because various tax and other issues needed to be addressed. ICAI Knowledge Base
A revised roadmap was announced in 2014, leading to phased implementation beginning with voluntary application and then mandatory application for specified classes of companies from 2016–17. ICAI Knowledge Base
Today, Ind AS sits within India's statutory financial reporting framework. The standards are notified by the Ministry of Corporate Affairs under the Companies Act, 2013, following the statutory process and recommendations involving the National Financial Reporting Authority. ICAI
11. So what is the relationship between all these names?
This is probably the simplest way to remember the entire story:
Name What it is Think of it as
SEC US securities regulator Regulator
FASB US accounting standard setter US standard setter
US GAAP US accounting framework US accounting rules
IASC International standard-setting body, 1973–2001 First major international standard setter
IAS Standards issued by IASC Earlier international standards
IASB International standard setter from 2001 Global standard setter
IFRS Standards issued by IASB, alongside continuing IAS International accounting standards
ICAI India's professional accounting body Indian accounting profession
ASB ICAI's Accounting Standards Board Developed Indian AS
AS Earlier Indian Accounting Standards India's earlier framework
Ind AS IFRS-converged Indian Accounting Standards India's current IFRS-converged framework
And there is one more important organisation in the modern Indian picture:
NFRA — National Financial Reporting Authority.
It has a statutory role in India's financial reporting and auditing oversight framework, while ICAI continues to play an important role in developing and recommending accounting standards. The standards are ultimately notified under the Companies Act framework. ICAI
12. The story in one continuous timeline
For your book, I think this timeline would be particularly useful:
1494
Luca Pacioli documents Venetian double-entry bookkeeping.
↓
19th–early 20th century
Corporations, stock markets and public investment expand.
↓
1929
US stock-market crash exposes weaknesses in investor protection and financial reporting.
↓
1933–34
US securities laws are enacted and the SEC is created.
↓
1930s onward
US accounting principles increasingly develop through professional standard-setting.
↓
1959
Accounting Principles Board succeeds the earlier Committee on Accounting Procedure.
↓
1973
FASB established in the US.
↓
1973
IASC established internationally.
↓
1977
ICAI establishes India's Accounting Standards Board.
↓
1979
India's first Accounting Standard, AS 1, is issued.
↓
1990s
International harmonisation gains momentum.
↓
2001
IASB replaces the IASC's standard-setting board.
↓
2001 onward
New international standards are issued as IFRS, while earlier IAS continue.
↓
2006
India decides to move towards IFRS convergence.
↓
2011
First set of Ind AS notified, but implementation postponed.
↓
2014
Revised Ind AS implementation roadmap announced.
↓
2015
Ind AS notified through the Companies (Indian Accounting Standards) Rules.
↓
2016 onward
Phased mandatory implementation begins for specified companies.
The deeper story
There is a lovely thread running through all of this, which I think would fit particularly well with the historical opening you are developing.
Pacioli gave bookkeeping a language.
The stock-market crash made society ask for trustworthy financial information.
The SEC made financial reporting a matter of investor protection.
US GAAP developed a national framework.
IASC tried to make accounting cross national borders.
IASB took that idea further and developed IFRS.
India first developed its own AS framework and eventually moved towards IFRS convergence through Ind AS.
So the story is not really about a succession of acronyms.
It is the story of trust becoming institutionalised.
A merchant once needed to trust his own books. Then a business owner needed to trust his accountant. A shareholder needed to trust the company's financial statements. An investor in one country needed to trust the accounts of a company in another. Eventually, the world needed a common set of principles that could make that trust possible across borders.
That is why accounting standards matter.
They are, ultimately, an attempt to answer one very old question:
When I cannot see the business for myself, can I trust the story its numbers are telling me?
That would make a strong bridge from your historical chapter into the next part of the book: “Why Accounting Standards Were Needed.”
No comments:
Post a Comment